Leading Actor Joined: 7/20/09
TWO "HAIRSPRAY" ONES:
Hayley Podschun as Penny in HAIRSPRAY
and
Gretchen Bieber as Velma in HAIRSPRAY
Updated On: 5/16/10 at 11:37 AM
Jessica Phillips as Diana in N2N. The only time an understudy has surpassed the regular actor, for me.
Broadway Star Joined: 12/16/06
I've seen many many shows (both plays and musicals)... Probably over 100...
The best performance I've ever seen from an understudy/standby was Lisa Brescia in Wicked.
Maureen Moore in Grey Gardens simply amazing.
Shannon Lewis as the Wife in Contact. The woman next to me said at intermission "that was the best standby EVER!" I agreed. Amazing.
Chorus Member Joined: 4/9/08
Shirley MacLaine for Carol Haney in the original production of Pajama Game.
Michelle London as Nessa and as Glinda in the 2nd National Tour of Wicked
"Shirley MacLaine for Carol Haney in the original production of Pajama Game."
You were there that night, Chuck012?
Mine would be Maryanne Plunkett, who went on for Carrie Fisher in "Agnes of God." That was a long time ago, but it's still the best understudy performance I've ever seen. Carrie was out a lot when she took over on Broadway for Amanda Plummer. And Maryanne eventually took over the role regularly. She also went on to win a Tony as Best Actress in a Musical for "Me and My Girl."
Mamie Parris as Mother in RAGTIME
Libby Winters as Heather in AMERICAN IDIOT
Featured Actor Joined: 12/16/06
The wonderful Jessica Phillips and Michael Berry in NEXT TO NORMAL. Both were sensational. The miraculous Maureen Moore in GYPSY.
* Randal Keith as Jean Valjean (yes, this was about 10 years ago)
* Another good word in for Karmine Alers as Mimi
* Joseph Dellger as the Phantom
* Steven Goldsmith as Frankie Valli
Jayne Paterson as Desiree in A Little Night Music
Linda Mugleston as Lilli in Kiss Me, Kate
Meghann Fahy as Natalie in Next to Normal
Paris Remillard as Claude in Hair
All fantastic, particularly the lovely Jayne Paterson.
Broadway Legend Joined: 1/28/08
-Jessica Phillips as Diana in Next to Normal
-Michelle London as Nessa in Wicked(2nd National Tour)
-Julie Hanson as Christine in Phantom of the Opera(she was the alternate)
I would say Rondi Reed on for Elizabeth Ashley as Mattie Fae in the closing performance of August: Osage County. Though, I don't know if you can really count that as an understudy. :-P
Updated On: 5/17/10 at 12:25 AM
Easily Victoire Charles subbing for Portia in RUINED.
Judy Kaye for Madeline Kahn in On the 20th Century
Stand-by Joined: 8/7/06
Michael Berry as Dan in Next to Normal.
J. Robert Spencer played the role brilliantly, and I was thrilled to see that Michael Berry gave a completely different, yet still incredible performance.
Adriane Lenox in CAROLINE OR CHANGE. TOTALLY different take on it than Tonya had. Both were brilliant but Lenox was astounding.
from awhile ago: Julie Reiber as Natalie in ALL SHOOK UP, as well as her standby performance as Elphaba in WICKED
Cara Cooper as Holly in WEDDING SINGER... so much better than Spanger.
Courtney Reed's Nina and Vanessa in IN THE HEIGHTS
and I recently saw Liz Pearce's 1st performance as Mrs. Wilkinson in BILLY ELLIOT. She was my favorite Mrs. W. by far... and on her first performance!
Broadway Legend Joined: 9/30/08
Maureen Moore in GREY GARDENS. A wonderful performer, and I had not seen her since NIGHT MUSIC at City Opera. I was thrilled.
Fuscia Walker as Effie in Dreamgirls. One of the best performances I've ever seen.
I have to agree about Maureen Moore in Grey Gardens. Amazing performance.
Joe Cassidy for NLB in Scoundrels.
and Joe Cassidy for Greg Jbara in Dirty Rotten Scoundrels.
Swing Joined: 8/15/06
I saw La Cage in London in January 2009. Hodge was out sick and his understudy was out sick, so they had Robert Maskell play Albin. Before curtain they explained to us that Maskell had never even walked through the entire role before, and had about a 30 minute put in. He was, however, AMAZING, and earned a huge standing ovation from everyone there.
Videos