" Crap. Thanks PJ.
This will be my first time seeing a physical production of Follies and I'm very excited, even without Bennett's choreography.
any reason as to why the choreo is not tied to this production as it is "A Chorus Line" and other Bennett shows?"
I have to say, even though I'm one of those obnoxious people who think the original choreography should nearly always be used, particularly when it's Bennett, the clips of choreography and the description of Who's That Woman make it sound like they did a good job. As I think PJ said, Who's That Woman has never been the great number it should be in any other production I've seen (Kathleen Marshall's version particularly comes to mind which misses the point completely) but...
As PJ said Avian when he choreographed the London production used some of Bennett's work, most notably Who's That Woman which was *almost* complete. The Papermill production was I believe choreographed by Mitchell, but it did use the *full* (ie slightly more complete than the London) Who's That Woman, though I've no idea who did the reconstruction--if it was Jerry, Avian, or? You can see both versions on "that site" I think.
As to your later question--I always try to get specifics on that. Robbins is one of the few choreographers who does have his work protected, at least for his last three major shows, WSS, Gypsy and Fiddler... Which I think is great, though I admit it gets silly when people try to do a different take on any of these musicals, like some recent Fiddlers, and still have to shoe horn in his choreography, which really most suits the original direction. I don't believe this is required with any of his earlier shows (many of which like On the Town have had their choreography lost anyway), although most times they do try to use his Uncle Tom's ballet for King and I.
Otherwise Chorus Line seems to be the only other show that has this rule. Bob Fosse never really cared (just like he didn't even much care about having film records of his choreography--that aspect of the legacy just didn't seem to matter to him), although I wish the last Sweet Charity had been forced to use his choreography considering what we got... Lots of people use Agnes DeMille's work for Oklahoma but it's not required, and her other work is barely used at all... Same for most of the big names, Kidd, etc...
As for Bennett--again I wish that Promises Promises had had to use his choreography--check out the new Turkey Lurkey to see how lacking it was--not to mention what was done to Dreamgirls in the last production even though most of Dreamgirls' original choreography was actually by Michael Peters, and I'd love to have his Side By Side, Drive a Person Crazy and especially Tick Tock in every Company, but Chorus Line seems to be the only one held to that rule...
And yes that was an exceptionally long ramble that's pretty off topic, so sorry--back to the topic.
And for the record, I agree that a non dancing Buddy, while not essential, does diminish his role. The Right Girl isn't a full on book song and isn't meant to be literal or realistic (just as many moments before Loveland goes all out, aren't meant to be)--so the dancing doesn't seem out of place as some suggest at all IMHO (to say so would be to say so does I'm Still Here, or even many of the ghost/memory moments).
Updated On: 5/12/11 at 01:32 AM