"What's your favorite show?" -- what answer would be the biggest turnoff?

You're at a bar or some social situation and meet someone you find attractive. You find out this person likes Broadway, so you ask them what their favorite musical on Broadway is right now. What answer could they give that would turn you off the most?

I'm not saying you should ultimately judge someone based on one preference, but I think a person's favorite show could tell you a lot about a person, like their sense of humor, their taste in music, whether they want to be deeply moved or mindlessly entertained, etc.

So, when you ask the question, what response do you least want to hear? Is this your least favorite show? Would you stop talking to them as a result?

Alternatively, what show would you most want to hear in your response? Is this also your favorite show?

Cats

---

i'd beat to death anyone who asked me that question if i thought they ascribed any sincere relevance to the answer. it would be necessary if for no other reason than to protect the gene pool from any accidental spillage of...that.

---

High school musical

Anyone asks me that question on a first date and I DTMFA.

Mamma Mia, Grease, Cats, Legally Blonde.

Saying it's your favorite show, yes. As in #1.

Spring Awakening.

Spring Awakening. Or for a play The Seafarer.

---

Kicky, I don't think you'd have to worry about dating me. From what I've seen you wouldn't even be allowed to get in line.

is this like the callout for all of the snobby broadway enthusiasts that think they are above others because they have "better" tastes in broadway shows?

kill me.

High School Musical

---

There are people who think "Rent" is God's gift to the world, and to those people I say, see more Broadway.