A number of people have made some valid criticisms of premium pricing. But I have to disagree with those who are singling out YF as if this show is doing something so fundamentally different from everyone else.
In particular, several of you seem to be bothered by the fact that YF has not opened yet, and so we don't really know whether or not it will be a good show. So what? A show's quality is just ONE of the many factors that draws people to buy tickets. It's the reason some shows will have a $10 million advance before opening night, and others will struggle for weeks to fill half their house even after getting good reviews. The fact is that Mel & Co. have a multi-Tony-award winning creative team and an all-star cast that is generating buzz and will sell lots of tickets at any price. This is a highly anticipated show. Sure, it still could bomb, but any producer of such a show, loaded with such big name talent, would be an absolute FOOL not to try and capitalize in on it, especially early on.
And if you have issues with premium pricing ticket policies in the first place, what difference does it make if the show is good or bad? Is it really any less offensive if someone buys a premium ticket to Jersey Boys or Grey Gardens than to Pirate Queen or Tarzan? Wouldn't you have the same issue either way?
And let's not fool ourselves that premium ticket prices will prevent people from also seeing other shows. Anyone who can spend $450 on a theatre ticket clearly is not going to have an issue spending another $120 or even another $400 to see another show if they want to. It's not an issue of common sense. Some people have the money to spend, and they'll spend it. Others don't and they won't.
I'm not saying I don't understand why some people on this board are upset by these policies. Pretty much everyone writing in here is a dedicated theatregoer, and I think a lot of us take it personally when we don't have access to the best seats to shows. But a lot of us are overstating the effect of premium pricing generally, and even if not, we're definitely overstating the impact of YF in particular on the policy.
If you want to take issue with YF, wait for it to open, see it, and bash away. Or don't see it out of protest. But don't blame the $451 premium ticket price for ruining Broadway. There are many more hands involved in that.
"This is wanting something, this is reaching for it,
This is wishing that a moment would arrive.
This is taking chances, this is almost touching, what the beauty is." --The Light in the Piazza