I'm surfing Itunes music store, and I have enough money to get one of those cast recordings. Which one?
L5Y
Thanks.
Broadway Star Joined: 1/20/06
It depends on what you like and what performers you prefer. My very personal recommendation is get The Last Five Years, the story is so emotional and touching, Sherie Renne Scott and Norbert Butz are very well-suited for the style of the score, I just got this album a couple of days ago and it's a very nice addition to my collection. Be aware that this is a two-actor musical so there won't be any ensemble pieces or big "One Day More"-like numbers, it's more a personal musical. Songs for a New World is a good album but I find The Last Five Years so touching and personal that I highly recommend it over Songs.
I'd say L5Y. I've actually preformed a lot of the Songs for a New World songs before and find the soundtrack...lacking. The cast isn't that great. As Foscas said, L5Y is a two man show, but Norbert and Sherie do it amazing and it has some of Jason Robert Brown's best work (in my opinion of course, the other amazing songs being in Parade).
Happy Shopping!
You honnestly can't go wrong with either one.
Stand-by Joined: 9/6/05
They're both good, but L5Y is better. The songs are great and the story is great. It kind of bothers me that SFANW doesn't have a story, but some of the songs are definitely worth a listen.
L5Y is my vote, though.
Well L5Y seems to have won... thanks for all your help! Now I have to go finish homework in time for Desperate Housewives.
Night.
no...SONGS!
Featured Actor Joined: 1/8/06
Songs for a New World...Both are great but SFANW I enjoy just a little bit more.
Broadway Legend Joined: 12/13/04
definitely TL5Y. no question.
it'll get you hooked on jason robert brown's music instantly, then you'll go back out and buy SFANW.
it's just gorgeous. definitely in my top 5 favorite cast recordings.
Get Parade--it's better than either of them
Which one has the most belting?
They both have belting, but for different vocal ranges. L5Y is pretty much a soprano and a tenor, while Songs for a New World has stuff that fits well in a mid-range voice (like mine ).
Broadway Legend Joined: 1/3/05
Both! But if you can really truly choose only one, The Last 5 Years. Beatiful, amazing, heartbreaking.
Understudy Joined: 1/11/06
I think Songs for a New World has better individual songs, but the Last 5 years has a better overall sound. If you want to listen to just 1 or 2 songs, get Songs for a New World. If you want to listen to the whole musical all the way through, get Last 5 years.
I do however think the Schmuel Song from L5Y is amazing on its own!
Last 5 Years. JRB's musical voice is more developed and the songs are better.
Along with the fact that it actually has a running story.
you honestly can't go wrong with either. if you are not familiar with him, I would say go with songs first, because that is his first recording, and it is more like a revue of great songs with awesome performers. get used to this cd, and see where he's coming from, then by last five years and see how much he improved when writing for character and story.
my vote is for L5Y...no doubt
I prefer Songs for a New World.
for me, I cannot live without Last 5 Years. 'If I Didn't Believe in You' is my new favorite song. it is so....sort of romantic, but more...ugh, i don;t know. but if a guy sang that to me, i would melt.
Videos