Highland Guy said: "Dan6 said: "Jarethan said: "I disagree re Dick Van Dyke. IMO, he has lived a long time, but I don’t see what great things he did other than his TV show. Also disagree re Channing...too limited a portfolio.
I personally think Glenn Close should be next, with Peters or Lupone seriously viable. "
Yup, he hasn’t done much of anything...which is why he’s wonfive Emmys, a Tony, a Grammy, has been inducted into the Television Hall ofFame, and received the SAG Life Achievement Award. But other than that, yeah, no great things."
Thank you for the reality check, Dan6. Appreciate your post!"
I like Dick Van Dyke, but I honestly believe he peaked in the sixties. I acknowledge that he has worked a lot and everyone likes him, but how much of what he had done (other than Birdie and the Dick Van Dyke Show, which went off the air 55 years ago), would be a contributing factor to getting such an honor. I looked at the IMDB database, which covers TV and film work (which is were he reallyfocused) and it does not approach Glenn Close or Jessica Lange or Jane Fonda (who is never going to get one) in impressiveness. You put together everything Bette Midler has done and his resume pales IMO. Peters and Lupone are theatre legends (an incredibly overused word, but appropriate there) with enormous portfolios. And I am only talking performers.
Someone mentioned Alan Menken, who has to be incredibly deserving. I have no doubt there are others.
When you reflect that those 5 slots cover film and TV, stage, opera, ballet, rock, classical music, country music, rock music, there are rarely no more than 2 slots (and usually not that many) allocated to film / tv performers. I just don't see DVD deserving one of those limited slots ahead of the peopleI have mentioned above.
Updated On: 2/5/20 at 10:06 AM