There's been lots of talk about APPLAUSE here lately. ENCORES (or is it REPRISE) is doing it in concert with Sheryl Lee Ralph as Margo. APPLAUSE was exciting because of Lauren Bacall's Tony winning performance. IT HAS THE SHOCKINGLY worst score EVER for a Tony award winning best musical. The overture is deceptively excellent. "But Alive," and the title song are the only ones that are pretty good and some are ok like "Who's That Girl," but this is a dreadful score. It stuns me that this score was written by the same people who wrote BYE BYE BIRDIE and ANNIE.
The best HIGHLIGHT of the original Broadway production was the fabulously staged curtain call bow that Ron Field did for Lauren Bacall. It was magnificent and goosebump inducing. Penny Fuller was excellent in APPLAUSE and Bonnie Franklin got a Tony nomination(as did Fuller in the same supporting category) although I have never really cared much for Franklin as a performer.
Len Cariou was his lifeless, usual performing self and his singing comes off particularly poor on the recording. The ABC television production (I purchased it on video a few years back)--it is a hoot to watch--I remember how thrilled I was when it was gonna be televised when I was a kid, and I couldn't understand why some of the cast seemed to be speaking in British accents and I was disappointed at all the material left out of the TV version. Bacall's performance did not work very well in the televised version. "It" was much too big for the small screen. She was electrifying onstage. And I must say, that Anne Baxter who replaced her was awfully marvelous and sang the role a great deal better. For the few who may not know, Anne Baxter played Eve in the film ALL ABOUT EVE on which APPLAUSE is based. In the musical, Anne Baxter played Margo, so she kinda came full circle, it was inspired and interesting casting. Ms. Baxter was as excellent as Margo as was her Oscar nominated performance as Eve in the film.
Unfortunately, APPLAUSE is third rate Strouse and Adams and forth rate Comden and Green. The costumes provided for them and the leading ladies themselves were great. But this show is not one of the greats. For those who saw the original production on Broadway, remember that Alan King appeared in the show? He was on television monitors placed throughout the theater and when the overture ended the monitors had the videotaped Alan King "hosting the Tonys or something to that effect," and he of course introduced MARGO CHANNING. The tv monitors went black as the glittering and dazzling Bacall strided to center stage, live and in person:)
"Blow out the candles Robert and make a wish. Want something, want SOMETHING."