Just got out of the Sunday PM show. Unfortunately, Andrew was out (I had a feeling this might happen with so many shows), but there is really nothing you can do to avoid this (until they publish a schedule). The backup was very good, but I can't help wishing I saw Andrew.
As for the rest of the cast, Christina Bennington is just simply amazing. I saw her in London, and I think she has gotten even better! And this without the regular Strat! Her voice is magnificent and her chemistry with (backup) Strat was very good. She was the real star of the show.
The rest of the cast was excellent. Lena Hall and Bradley Dean were great together! I really enjoyed their performances. Everything they were in were major highlights of the show. I don't want to get too much into the rest of the cast, but I highly enjoyed ALL of the performances.
As for the special effects, yes what you read is all true. But I don't think it takes away too much from the show. The Dominion theater (the shows permanent home for a while in London) was obviously a much better theater for a show like this. That said, the producers I'm sure did the best they could with what they have. If you saw the show in London, you will miss the effects. If you didn't, you will still be happy with what they did. There is still plenty of pizzazz.
As for seating, I sat in the front row center of the Grand Tier. Absolutely loved the seats. I think these may be the best seats in the theater. You can see everything very clearly, no obstructions at all. As for other seating hints, I would NOT sit far right (when facing stage) on the Grand Tier/lower Mezzanine level. It seemed there was constant lights being projected into the audience faces. Now I didn't sit there, but I can only imagine that would be super annoying. But sitting far left is also a problem as you probably won't be able to see the projections on stage. I would think Center Orchestra and Center Grand Tier and Center lower Mezzanine are where you should shoot for. Avoid far left or far right. Too many issues...
The crowd was pretty good for a Sunday night. I was concerned because the day before the show it looked like there were a ton of unsold seats. They must have sold a lot of (discounted) tickets the day of the show. Crowd was pretty enthusiatic although we did here some weird laughing from the Mezzanine or Balcony at inopportune times. Either I was missing stuff, or people were laughing at things they shouldn't have been. That being said, I found the show funnier then London. Most of the comedy bits came from Lena & Bradley (and not to say anything bad about Sharon or Rob) but I just really enjoyed Lena & Bradley's comedic timing.
Most of the changes previously mentioned are correct. The show is slightly shorter with the removal of the opening Act 2 song. While I missed it, most people are still saying the show is too long or some songs go on too long. They are probably right. The main exception would be "Anything For Love". I found it too long in London but was perfectly okay in NY. I doubt it is shorter though --- I was just looking forward to hearing Lena Hall and Bradley Dean sing their parts, so it felt shorter. They were great. [POSSIBLE SPOILER] They did not drag Strats body off during first intermission. Instead, he quickly ran off when lights dimmed. Not sure if this is a change or it was due to the different actor. [END OF SPOILER].
Well that is all I can think of for now. I actually liked this cast and the comedy bits better here then London (didn't see Andrew as Strat for either). But the overall London production was (understandably) better.
If you like Meatloaf, Jim Steinman, or this music you should love the show. Great performances, high energy and bombastic fun. For those who don't like this type of show, nothing I am going to say will convince you otherwise. I love Christina Bennington & hopefully I will see Andrew as Strat one day. But I have a feeling it won't be in the USA.
Updated On: 8/4/19 at 11:30 PM