HBBrock said: "Even though I had a strong feeling the lead of the show (Andrew Polec) was going to be out tonight, I was pretty aggravated when I looked at the At This Performance board and saw that he was out (he took last Sunday night off too, and I am sure he was resting for The Today Show this morning). So aggravated that I put in a half effort to ask about exchanging tickets. Once the box office said I would need to talk to the House Manager, I kind of said screw it and we decided to stay. 7th Row Center Orchestra was too good to pass up.
The understudy, Will Branner, ended up winning me over by the end, and actually got the loudest applause at the curtain call. Being an understudy is hard because the audience is often disappointed you are on, and you have even more to prove. But understudies do amazing work.
What a great time! This show gave me everything I hoped it would. Was it campy and cheesy? Absolutely! But it was so much fun. The cast was fantastic. The one time the camp fully took over and I started giggling was when Bradley Dean sang “What Part of My Body Hurts The Most.” But I applaud his putting 100% into it! He was awesome.
People use the “Blow the roof off of the place” saying too much, and I try not to use it too much, but watching Christina Bennington and Lena Hall sing “It’s All Coming Back To Me Now” is unmissable. Those two ladies belted it out and gave me chills. They were both incredible.
The ensemble had some serious vocalists in it, and they really did Jim Steinman’s music really, really well.
I definitely recommend this, but know that it’s not a Broadway show. It is some sort of rock opera/concert with costumes and a set/pretty corny story.....but you will leave smiling for sure.
The show is like watching an 80s music video. I will be singing “I’d Do Anything For Love (But I Won’t Do That)” all week."
HBBrock, I was also at last night performance and also 7th row center orchestra. You must be the nice people I was sitting next to during the show. Like you, I was also initially disappointed that Andrew Polec was out, but pleasantly surprised by understudy Will Branner. I saw him previously as Tony in West Side Story last year at Barrington Stage, so I knew he was good but I was still surprised by how well he sang these songs. I have tickets to two more shows later in the run. Hopefully I'll get to see Andrew Polec for one of those, but now I'll be comparing him to what I saw from Will last night.
As for the show itself, the story that ties the songs together is weak, but the actors sing the hell out of these songs. Every single song is arranged and sung beautifully. The staging, the effects, the choreography are all extra and secondary to the songs and the actors singing them. If you're a fan of Jim Steinman's songbook, this is a must-see. I had a great time.
Audience reward tickets were Row G orchestra center. Excellent seats. I just checked. They have one ticket left for August 29. If I lived in NYC. I would jump at that.