dramamama611 said: "No, it wasn't surviving with Oak. Sales were dusmal; Patinkin was a life jacket."
I’d also say that Comet has been dogged by reports that the revenue was mismanaged, that somehow not one of its off-Broadway productions recouped despite being popular. So the Broadway production was on more unstable footing than many shows from the get go. Add to that the lack of substantial advance sales, it was destined to close.
By comparison, Hello, Dolly! seems to be well managed shows (say what you will, but Rudin appears to know how to turn a profit). There are reports the show has recouped, but we may never know for sure. For the show to have strong advance sales, it has been clear it needs a star in the lead. Not sure why they couldn’t find another talented star to take over, but I’ll say this...
Let’s be glad it was revived. We needed this show as surely as we needed The Band’s Visit. The corner offers an escape from our troubling times while the latter. reminds that hospitality can be found in the most unexpected places, even those places we might expect to be rejected.
I’d also say that it’s human nature to want our favorite shows to run forever or at least for a long time. But if we want new works and revivals we have to make room for them. Of course, the last mostly dismal year for new musicals doesn’t inspire much hope. I am a fan of both Dolly (saw it with both Bette and Bernadette) and The Great Comet (missed the Broadway run, but saw the last off-Broadway run).
I also think we probably underestimate how high the weekly nut is for most shows while forgetting that just barely meeting the weekly nut does not contribute to paying back the investors.