saw tonight's performance. did not love this as much as everyone else here (womp womp womp) BUT very glad this is on Broadway!
This is a broad strokes sitcom. Whenever it leans into humor, it shines (see, Michael Urie, who is over the top chewing scenery in the best way). But it drags when it leans into the schmaltzy saccharine moments which pander to the Broadway audience and it does that a whole bunch. And you can see the "revelation" that comes 2/3 of the way through coming a mile away.
THAT SAID: the audience was looooving this, and it is an ORIGINAL work by a new playwright making people LAUGH and APPLAUD, and it tells the kind of unabashedly Black story that we need more of on stage (and especially in on a big high profile stage like CITS). Even if I didnt love it, im THRILLED that its on Broadway and I want it to find its audience and have a healthy run. Ebony Marshall-Oliver was fantastic, and Norm Lewis had his moments, too. (Natasha Yvette Williams has a pretty thankless role, but did fine work with it, though I found myself hoping she'd have a chance to break into song).
as an aside, the audience felt very evenly divided between young gay men (and quite a few very well dressed drag queens) and Black couples/families. The inside-baseball theater references delighted the former group, and the very many inside-baseball Black church references delighted the other. (My childhood experiences in Black churches made me chuckle a bunch but my friends were lost at many of the jokes, for example). I did cringe at how many times Michael Urie's character is referred to as "White" or sort of painted as "White" with very broad strokes when he is pointedly Jewish. And without spoiling anything, I thought the deceased character (thats not a spoiler, it kicks off at a funeral) is given a bit of a pass by the script...
anyway, go see this because it should be seen and not everyone's a curmudgeon like me. Our TDF seats were great (Row A), but there isnt a bad seat in this house for this show except for those small sections on the very end of the two legs of the "U" that seem to me to be quite uncomfortably situated.