CHICKEN & BISCUITS Previews — Page 7

gibsons2 said: "
"

Calling out someone's bs is not ugly and I'm being very polite"

Yes you've been nothing but polite and pleasant. The BS here, just to be clear, is that something made me cringe and you think I was wrong to have cringed, and wrong to have explained why when asked, and then wrong to have corrected your taking a cue from Sutton Ross (always a mistake!) that it was OK to announce what Judaism is and is not, and announce what I am and what I am not, and what I am therefore allowed to say.

YvanEhtNioj said: "
this is literally a nonissue."

I definitely agree its a non-issue. @Ripped i dont know if you've seen the play, but I think everyone is playing rather exaggerated stereotypes and I dont think Logan Leibowitz is treated any differently or harshly or inappropriately than anyone else. Certainly wasn't an issue for me. (I liked this play. I loved Urie's performance. The degree to which people are this worked up to the point of going off on what Jewish people are or arent--talking about them in a way they'd never talk about any other minority--says lots.)

RippedMan said: "

I just think the making the white a Jewish white gay seems... obvious and not clever.

"

Eh, theres a very uppity conservative Church Lady, a very loud and scantily clad hairdresser from Atlanta... this is a funny play but its not subtle and the characters sure aren't. I merely noticed- and would be curious if other sane theatergoers did as well-- that Logan's Judaism is prominently mentioned and then disappears when it comes time for some discussion of the various ways in which these characters have struggled- the gay son of a pastor, the mistreated woman, etc.

I just noticed that his Whiteness overtook his Otherness rather quickly. The only way thats a big deal is if you dont think Jewishness if an Otherness, which many here do, but I really hope that comment isnt taken as basis to be angry or not see this play, and if you havent @Ripped, its worth seeing especially given the many cheap tickets available. if ANYTHING what bugged me most about the play is how the central, unseen character gets a major pass....but that was an observation that passed muster with the hall monitors here, so it got lost i guess.

RippedMan said: "I think a lot of people are just confused about race. Like, YOU (meaning POC) can call us out (hence this show) but WE (white ppl) cannot? Right?"



this is just a whole other topic-- I tend to think everyone should be able to call out everyone else with sincerity, and that POC being derisive/derogatory towards White people isn't the best. I think that in a society with one group in the majority and in power regardless, the minority will always have more leeway and justifiable anger in this space, and more of a responsibility to call out.

THAT SAID, while an interesting topic for rational adults, this aint that space, and more importantly, this has NOTHING to do with Chicken and BIscuits which doesn't "Call out" anyone all that drastically. Slave Play was a big soap box; this is a very special episode of a well-written sitcom. My wincing at the way the White Gay Jew was folded up into one Big Privileged Person should NOT be read (as it has been here, willfully) to mean I thought the play was a lecture at/for White people or anything like that.

this isn't a call out play. this isnt an angry play. its a funny two hours that needs less saccharine and an intermission.

YvanEhtNioj said: "-said something stupid
-got called out on it
-tried to correct it
-still made no sense
-is now upset for being called out

Had you not “cringed” at a white person being called white, we wouldn’t be here. Lol. Digress, tho. "

Great summary which should put the end to this conversation. Although I don't think it's not going to be the last topic about the upcoming plays written by black playwrights when someone bring up the nonsense of "reversed racism". Just wait till Slave Play comes out again, everyone's favorite bag to punch.

gibsons2 said: ""

Omg, one of the few plays came out where black people are center andand not just a token part of the ensemble and you're getting offended at them calling a white guy "white"... when they talk amongst each other. And that's what literally any monoethnic family would discussif one of itsmembers brings a partner of another race.. What else do you getoffended by on the daily basis?"

I so very agree with this point. This isn't a play about Logan and the play doesnt have to be and it would be patently wrong to dismiss this play because of one minor reaction mentioned on a message board.

As I believe someone said above (oh, im sorry, as *i* said above), its a Black story and its GREAT that its on Broadway and we need more of it and I hope lots of people go and see this play.

And as I believe I also said repeatedly, I wasn't offended by anything. So you have to ask yourself what would compel someone like gibson to continuously pretend that anyone claimed to be offended here by anything in this play and even more egregiously suggest anyone complained about the focus on a Black family when literally the precise opposite was stated. (And continue to repeat, falsely, that anyone in the play refers to this dude as The White Guy, in a valiant example of Missing a Point like I havent seen in a long while).

gibsons2 said: "RippedMan said: "YvanEhtNioj said: "RippedMan said: "It is interesting that given the past year, we are now using the "white gay" as a stock character. Even though that's what we're fighting against? putting people in boxes? But yet here we are? Hm. So much for progress."

The play is about a black family and meant to be realistic. If I, a gay BLACK man, brought home a boyfriend who wasn’t black..literally the first thing my family would say is “giiiiirrrlll did y’all hear Jordan dating that white boy”

this is literally a nonissue."

Totally get it. But, in the reverse, wouldn't we all point fingers and call that racist?

I just think the making the white a Jewish white gay seems... obvious and not clever.

"

Omg, one of the few plays came out where black people are center andand not just a token part of the ensemble and you're getting offended at them calling a white guy "white"... when they talk amongst each other. And that's what literally any monoethnic family would discussif one of itsmembers brings a partner of another race.. What else do you getoffended by on the daily basis?"

Make no mistake, I'm not offended by any of it. Just pointing out the 'having your cake and eating it to" of it all. That's all. I haven't seen the piece, so not commenting on the actual play. I totally get when black people hang out they're gonna call their one white friend their white friend, duh, get that. I'm just saying if it were the opposite we'd all be up in arms and canceling the production. That's all. Moving on.

JBroadway said: "Woah, I popped into this thread just to find out about rush info...what a bizarre series of twists and turns I've missed!

For the record: I'm an Ashkenazi Jew of Eastern European descent...and I'm white. Judaismis a religion, being an Ashkenazi Jewis an ethnicity, but neither are a race. It's a nuanced thing, but it's important recognize that nuance. I don't doubt that there are white Jews who don't consider themselves white, but they would be wrong. Possibly they feel that because Jews have historically been persecuted, that qualifies as being non-white, but persecution and racism are not synonymous. Anti-Semitism and racism have somewhat different histories, they often function differently, and they manifest differently in modern society.

One of the main overlaps is that white supremacists don't consider white Jews to be white. But I don't take my cues from white supremacists when checking a box on a form."

Thats a perfectly reasonable position to take re identifying as White--i always used to think of my White Jewish family as White Like Everyone Else-- but it isnt that simple. And I certainly don't get how anyone can declare Jews not to be a race-- Judaism is a religion, but there is a racial group of people that derive from Ashkenazi (Northern/Eastern/Central European) Jews and one that derives from Sefardi Jews. There are lots of Jews who are the product of inter-racial relationships, or who "opt in" and are 1000% Jewish as a result, but when I take a DNA test, 25% of my genes dictate that I'm of Ashkenazi Jewish origin. That isnt a religion or culture.

can the moderators PLEASE get this thread back on the rails

TheSassySam said: "I would really love to see this show, but will be in town a few days after it closes. Any chance we may get an extension?"



I'm pretty sure that Circle-in-the-Square has another show booked into it already.