Saw the matinee on Saturday and I was completely blown away. I saw this show three times in the last six months of its original run (the first time being on my fifteenth birthday) and have been madly in love with it since then. I still think this production is perfect. I'm still taking in some of the dialogue, costume, and choreography changes; I'm not crazy about some of the new costumes, but can't decide yet if it's just because they're different or because I actually don't like them. All the other changes I either thought were improvements, or didn't have much of an effect on my overall feelings about the piece.
Seeing Alan Cumming as the Emcee was without question the highlight for me. From what some others have posted here I was worried that I too would feel like he was "phoning it in." Granted, I did not see his original performance, but he exceeded every expectation I had--and my expectations were very high. I felt like after having seen so many people play "Alan Cumming as the Emcee," it was jarring to finally see Alan BE the Emcee. It was like loving and studying the Mona Lisa for years, knowing it inside and out, then finally going to the Louvre and seeing it in person. I actually had a hard time paying attention to some of the scenes because I just loved watching his reactions to what was happening in the play--natural, effortless, stunning. I was particularly taken aback by "If You Could See Her." I've never enjoyed or felt as shocked by it as I did seeing Alan perform it. Breathtaking.
I'm not 100% sold on Michelle Williams. I think she is a fantastic actress and her book scenes--along with "Cabaret"--were perfection, but her early club numbers were just a little off to me. Sally shouldn't be a good or polished singer or dancer, but I do think she should be an extraordinarily confident and singer and dancer--even if her confidence is entirely unfounded. Michelle didn't seem quite there yet. I think she'll continue to improve, and I certainly enjoyed her performance as is, but there is room to grow. (Also, as a side note, MAN is she tiny!)
Linda and Danny were fantastic. There was a post-show discussion with them afterward and they were incredibly sweet and gracious then, too. One older gentleman took the microphone when the audience had the chance to ask questions and said that he, as someone who lived through the Holocaust, feels that Cabaret is more than an important musical, but an important story that needs to continue to be shared. (There was much more to it and it was more eloquent than I'm remembering--the audience applauded when he finished speaking.) Anyway, after the discussion was over, Danny went into the audience to talk to the man and asked to take a photo with him. It was very touching.
I will say that the production did not seem as shocking to me as it did the first time around, but it's hard to say how much of that is the difference between seeing it as a fifteen-year-old versus as an almost-twenty-six-year-old. Or the difference between seeing it in 2003 versus 2014 (we are living in a post-Gaga, post-Miley world, after all). Anyway, the shock value was never the important part of the production to me. It's just a brilliant interpretation of a nearly flawless show--and that, in my opinion, is still the case.
Updated On: 4/21/14 at 10:51 PM