The revival was a conundrum, and I agree with those who have said that Lapine shouldn't have directed the revival. It seemed forced, like he was making sporadic changes just to be able to say he made changes. Little Red and Jack interupting Cindy's song was distracting and rude. We get it, they've all grown and learned through their experiences, but they already had their friggin' numbers! The extra wolf and especially the Three Little Pigs was not necesary. The lyric change in Last Midnight wasn't bad, but not as good as the original. Vanessa Williams gave one of the worst performances I've ever seen on a Broadway stage. And the fact that Little Red and Jack were played much younger was disturbing. There is a major sexual overtone to this show. And to see these young kids go through some of these things was uncomforting (ie the Wolf's "seduction" of Little Red). Plus, since this was very obviously directed towards a more "family" market, the occasional blue jokes were hard to take as well (like the large, flaccid penis joke mentioned earlier).
The only change I really liked about this production was Milky White. But I think it is quite telling when the stupid COW is the thing that steals the show and all that the reviewers wrote about!
And the set being made of books wasn't all that innovative. My community theater used the same concept back in 1992. I will say though, the set was beautiful. I especially loved the intermission curtain that looked like a huge pile of giant fairy tale books.
VW's hair stood on end during the Witch's trance in the middle of her opening rap. She hissed like a snake, her snake like staff came to life and its eyes glowed red (which just made me think of Jafar from Disney's Aladdin) and her hair went crazy.
I just felt that the whole revival was lifeless and flat. I got a MUCH better sense of fairy tale and wonder in the first act of the original than I did in the revival, hence the second act was that much more heart breaking originally. In the revival I almost didn't care about the people as they died.
Anyway, that being said, INTO THE WOODS is one of my all time favorite shows and I did like the revival. I just felt it didn't hold a candle to the original.
<-- Tevye, FIDDLER ON THE ROOF, March 2018