barcelona20 said: "I know Sondheim prefers actors but it's going to be really hard to erase the power of Raul when it comes to Being Alive."
I don’t think we should keep holding Esparza’s take on the role in such high esteem. His Being Alive is brilliant (although his reading of “mock me with praise” is perhaps too melodramatic), but I think he often came across as too cold and aloof in the part. It didn’t really make sense why so many people would become so attached to him. A good Bobby/Bobbi should have more warmth.
“Lenk almost ---almost -- even makes the now extremely bizarre marriage proposal to her (gay) best friend work”
I had wondered how the show tackled this moment. Yeah, that sounds a bit clumsy, but we can always assume that Jamie is bisexual. Or maybe, since the show already hints at Bobbi being bi, she’s just much more fluid when it comes to gender and sexuality. It’s worth noting, her proposing to a gay man could simply drive home the line “You have to love somebody, not just some body.
Anyway, I like the hint of Bobbi being bi. It’s nothing too overt, so it probably pleases Sondheim since she can just be considered bicurious. And after all, it’s much less explicit than the original dialogue about Bobby having “a homosexual experience”. I’m guessing that’s been worked around with the gender change. No need to tell me what happened, I’m seeing it in less than two weeks.
Anyway, I find it strange that some people are saying Lenk doesn’t have a powerhouse voice, as I thought she sounded marvelous in The Band’s Visit. I’m sure she just needs a little bit of time to adjust to the role vocally. After all, it’s not like there’s much precedent for the role music wise when it comes to a woman playing her.
Anyway, from what I hear it sounds like this production could be earning acting nominations for Lenk, LuPone (whose obviously going to win), Doyle, Simard (her role is the least showy of these five, but it sounds like she’s making the absolute most of it), and Elder. Is there anybody else who could be in contention for some awards love? I’m guessing there aren’t anymore women, as the remaining female roles really aren’t showy parts at all.
Anyway, I sure hope this production runs long enough so that if Matt Doyle ever leaves, Brandon Uranowitz can take over to play Jamie. He’s said before that after seeing Veanne Cox’s Tony nominated work as Amy, it became a dream role for him, and now’s the perfect time for him to do the role. Given the fact that Assassins was originally a limited engagement, he could probably get out of it in time.
I’m super excited to see this production and I plan to post my thoughts on here once I do. I got high hopes.