Yes, Bradley Dean was on today, and he was perfectly fine, but I can't imagine that it would have mattered less who played Zhivago. The most thrilling performer in the world could have performed the part naked and it still wouldn't have risen this dreary afternoon's show up out of the concrete colored rock pile it sits in for the whole 3 hours.
Look, I'm a set designer, and I've mentioned before that I'm pretty bigoted about one thing: if a show has a great set, I can forgive a lot of weaknesses in the script ( a la my rave for AN AMERICAN IN PARIS), but if a show has a crappy set, then no amount of brilliant writing can save it in my eyes. And Zhivago's set? Sadly the second choice. Act I had a cold kind of neoclassical stature to it, but God help any spark of life survive the onslaught of grey concrete that strangled Act II. I still held out hope that the lovely Winter Palace remembered so fondly from the film would salvage the day, but alas no-- a barbarity of plexi icicles and a series of Dr. Caligari's window frames descended into the cement gloom like literal daggers in the heart of any nascent romance the lovers were trying to drum up. Arggghhhh.
The score? Well the best of it reminded me of tunes from Lucy Simon's infinitely better SECRET GARDEN, now saddled with lyrics that always hit each idea squarely on the head with the force of a sledgehammer. If Yuri is such an inspirational poet, why on earth couldn't we have heard any his lovely poetry set to music? Most everything sounded cloned from other through-sung scores I've loathed (Jekyll and Hyde, Love Never Dies), and I swear one song for the Bolshevik revolutionaries in a tavern seemed cribbed directly from FIDDLER's "To Life." It was all sung and played with conviction, so there's that.
My heart goes out to the folks both onstage and back, who have obviously labored mightily to make this story come to life. It's a property that ought to work gangbusters in musical form. Maybe one day we'll get a version that finds all the wonder and magic in the story amidst the surrounding tragedy. This one nailed the tragedy, and very little else.
Updated On: 4/5/15 at 06:13 PM