We’re coming up on 23 years (My God, how time flies) since one of my favorite musicals came and went. It’s stuck with me all these years and bootleg recordings have solidified if as one of my favorite scores that I always listen to on repeat, especially around this time of year.
And dear Broadway producers who are reading this thinking “My God that’s a wonderful idea!”, maybe do it with Kate Baldwin or Carmen Cusack as Gretta?
Thanks, money people. Merry Christmas.
Stand-by Joined: 7/30/16
I had the privilege of seeing the immersive production at the Irish Rep in 2016 with Kate Burton and Boyd Gaines. It was spectacular.
Updated On: 12/26/21 at 01:37 PMBroadway Legend Joined: 7/29/19
You’re like the 10th person to bring this up to me and I want to know so much about this show!! Guess I’ll have to do some YouTubing!
The immersive production was so beautiful. Or course it wasn't this musical I mentioned here, but it was a full on experience I hope will come back to the city soon. I won the lottery for that one, so for $25 (or whatever it was), I got to sit next to Kate Burton at dinner and just have the most amazing time. The actors all broke character for that hour so I wasn't sitting next to Gretta but actually Burton, who was a fabulous dinner companion. The way the actors interacted with us "Normals" was something I'll honestly never forget.
I’d settle for a proper cast album.
I saw the original production and despite (or maybe partly because of?) Christopher Walken's complete lack of singing ability, I remember enjoying it a good deal. I can't imagine that a commercial Broadway revival would make a single dime, but maybe Roundabout could do it, or Encores or Manhattan Concert Productions.
Oh, there's plenty of A-list 40/50-something actors they could get for Gabriel that would ensure an audience.
Broadway Legend Joined: 9/1/14
My dream production would have Hugh Jackman as Gabriel, Judy Kuhn as Gretta, Victoria Clark as Aunt Julia, Christine Ebersole as Aunt Kate, Lauren Ambrose as Molly Ivors, Steven Boyer as Freddy Malins and Annaleigh Ashford as Mary Jane, among others.
Hugh would be wonderful. I’d been thinking more along the lines of a Clive Owen or Colin Firth.
I remember watching the original a night of December, to a half empty theater. I adored it and wonder if its charm can survive after all this time.
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/13/09
I remember going to see this a few days into 2000 (and just now realizing that it was still in previews at that point). I was in town for a college theatre department trip where we only had three shows that were part of our 5 day itinerary, so we had a lot of free time otherwise to pick and choose as we pleased. A friend and I were obsessed with Alice Ripley and Emily Skinner because of Side Show, so we chose this for a Saturday matinee while some of the others went to Miss Saigon. It was hauntingly beautiful in its simplicity and I would love to see it done again, though I do agree that it would need to be a limited run by one of the non-profits with a big name star to have any sort of success as a Broadway revival.
Jordan Catalano said: "Hugh would be wonderful. I’d been thinking more along the lines of a Clive Owen or Colin Firth."
Because Clive Owen's previous 2 Broadway shows did so well? :)
I don't see a Broadway revival of this EVER happening. It has no cultural footprint because of the short original run + album situation. Perhaps off-Broadway in a subscription theatre (Irish Rep? 2nd Stage?), or someplace like Greg Mosher's Hunter College company which has done the recent Richard Nelson plays.
ErmengardeStopSniveling said: "Jordan Catalano said: "Hugh would be wonderful. I’d been thinking more along the lines of a Clive Owen or Colin Firth."
Because Clive Owen's previous 2 Broadway shows didsowell? :)
I don't see a Broadway revival of this EVER happening. It has no cultural footprint because of the short original run + album situation. Perhaps off-Broadway in a subscription theatre (Irish Rep? 2nd Stage?), or someplace like Greg Mosher's Hunter College company which has done the recent Richard Nelson plays."
Also, not every show is ideally suited to Broadway -- as I'd argue the original production proves. The show was an impossible sold out hit at Playwrights Horizons so it was hastily moved to Broadway, where it never found an audience. And unfortunately, since it's not recorded, it's largely forgotten. A shame, since it's one of the best musicals of the last 25 years.
I've always wondered why Irish Rep didn't do a revival, especially since it could be done with just a piano and a few actors playing instruments diegetically.
But also, how lovely would it be for someone like Chita to play Aunt Julia. I’m happy the show is remembered so fondly by others and just want more people to be able to discover it.
Sounds perfect for Encores. Rather see this than Into the Woods or Millie.
RippedMan said: "Sounds perfect for Encores. Rather see this than Into the Woods or Millie."
Would much rather see a small intimate approach, like the most recent Off Broadway Sweeney Todd.
Videos