Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Entertainment Weekly's 50 Best Plays (and 10 Greatest Musicals) Over the Past 100 Years — Page 4

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#79

Entertainment Weekly's 50 Best Plays (and 10 Greatest Musicals) Over the Past 100 Years

Are we really expecting a valid list with Oklahoma on it? Guys and Dolls too. 'Greatest Musicals' should only be applied to the non-bubblegum variety. Sure, Guys and Dolls and Oklahoma are cute, community theater shows, but they're not 'great'. Great should be a tour de force of a musical, something thought-provoking, that impacts you as you leave. Something that pushes the envelope.

Updated On: 6/1/14 at 04:31 AM

#80

Entertainment Weekly's 50 Best Plays (and 10 Greatest Musicals) Over the Past 100 Years

What a strange definition of "great".

Guys & Dolls (while overdone, and accessible) IS one of the best musicals every written -- no if, ands and buts about it.
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it? These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.
#83

Entertainment Weekly's 50 Best Plays (and 10 Greatest Musicals) Over the Past 100 Years

"Are we really expecting a valid list with Oklahoma on it? Guys and Dolls too. 'Greatest Musicals' should only be applied to the non-bubblegum variety. Sure, Guys and Dolls and Oklahoma are cute, community theater shows, but they're not 'great'. Great should be a tour de force of a musical, something thought-provoking, that impacts you as you leave. Something that pushes the envelope."

Do you know anything about the history of Oklahoma? During its time, Oklahoma definitely "pushed the envelope"--with the exception of Showboat, Oklahoma was the first wildly successful book musical, and it changed musical theater forever. "Guys and Dolls", on the other hand, is just a perfectly executed show. While reasonable people can and do differ about what goes on a list of the best musicals, both of those shows are iconic and I have no problem with including them.
#84

Entertainment Weekly's 50 Best Plays (and 10 Greatest Musicals) Over the Past 100 Years

"Guys and Dolls and Oklahoma are cute, community theater shows, "
Why is "community theater" so frequently used as a put-down, as in this case? My experience with community theater -- such as the Attic Ensemble in Jersey City -- is that they try to choose the best shows they can. The productions themselves may not be of professional quality. But it may well be one gauge of greatness that a particular show is continually chosen by communities all over the country.
#85

Entertainment Weekly's 50 Best Plays (and 10 Greatest Musicals) Over the Past 100 Years

It's interesting that only four of the musicals on EW's list make it to the Library of America's recent 16 Greatest American Musicals of the Golden Age: Oklahoma!, Guys and Dolls, Gypsy and Cabaret.

(Some of the shows not included in the new list, to be fair, were created after the "golden age.")


16 greatest American musicals of the Golden Age, according to the Library of America

Updated On: 11/28/14 at 11:57 PM

#90

Entertainment Weekly's 50 Best Plays (and 10 Greatest Musicals) Over the Past 100 Years

"You're a constant marvel. Nobody under the age of 70 like The Skin of Our Teeth."


Speak for yourself. I'm very far from that age, and I adore that play.


I think it's ridiculous that this list ignored Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, All My Sons, The Normal Heart, You Can't Take it With You, Private Lives... I understand there are limited slots, but are The Lieutenant of Inishmore and The Weir really deserving contenders? Lists like these usually have a consensus for the top 10, and then it's all up for grabs.


As for the question of female playwrights, I would love to see Paula Vogel, Sarah Ruhl, and Marsha Norman represented on the list.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $95