Finally saw it last night, and I really liked it overall, but I was so disappointed by Borle's performance. The man has multiple Tonys, so I can't wrap my head around how boring he was. My friend, with whom I attended, had no idea he was a successful Broadway actor and said he wasn't very good even before I could state my own opinion. His frustration, confusion, etc. at the end of Act I was non-existent.
As everyone else has stated, Block stole the show. Uranowitz was adorable, the son was good, and even Rannells, who can seem to be one-note, gave me some shades of a performance. I didn't 100% buy him as weaat the end (physically or vocally), but there were definitely moments of it. And his swagger was great at the beginning. The lesbians next door didn't have enough to do, so they were good but nothing that stood out. That's a shame because Betsy Wolfe is pretty incredible, and I am waiting for the role that lets her show all of her capabilities off. Maybe Frozen...
I knew of the show previously but didn't know it well. I feel like there are so many Jewish jokes that I didn't know how an audience unfamiliar with things like traif and a Bar Mitzvah would feel about it. I laughed my behind off at it all. And to people who said they hated the blocks, I found myself fascinated by everything they did with them. Before my eyes, the set became a house or a living room. It happened in front of me but I kind of never noticed it happening. Perhaps that says a lot about the characters themselves - Trina not realizing/acknowledging that her husband was gay, Marvin not realizing/acknowleding that Whizzer was sick, etc. when all of these things are right in front of them. Just a thought.