CarlosAlberto said: "TaffyDavenport said: "Penna2 said: "TaffyDavenport said: "Penna2 said: "BETTY22 said: "Wouldn't it be great id they record a special bonus track with Julie......
I have seen all 3 ladies in the role and JULIE was by far my favorite - she can sing and she is FUNNNNNNYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY"
No."
You haven't seen the show with either Julie or Lea, right? Videos don't count."
Because you say so? Only seeing the show LIVE is enough to qualify a person to have an opinion. I don't think either Julie or Beanie should be part of the album and I suspect that since it's a done deal, neither do the producers. Lots of people who are unable to see the show live are going to be buying this album. I will be one of them - mainly because I saw the videos."
You can say whatever you want, but, unless you've seen the entire show in person, you're simply not qualified to brush off the opinion of someone who has, multiple times. Your viewpoint with regard to the actresses' performances carries little weight."
^ Word! So tired of people opining without actually seeing the shows. These Broadway aficionados by way of YouTube crack me the F-Up"
Well, gee, not everyone has the money to travel to NYC to become a REAL Broadway aficionado and we are grateful to have YouTube so we can participate in theater. I know very well that live theater is different than a video - that said, comparing apples to apples - video to video, I think I can tell who I happen to like better. Doesn't mean someone else can't (obviously) have another opinion.
I simply objected to having another artist have a track on a CD when that artist isn't the star of the show and then all this other business about not being entitled to an opinion came up.