BorisTomashevsky said: "What happened with Jeremy Jordan and Newsies? He did Papermill and then Broadway, but was there some trouble in between?"
Jeremy Jordan was cast in the Papermill production run of Newsies in August of 2011, after it was already announced in June of 2011 that he would be staring Bonnie & Clyde on Broadway in late Fall of 2011. This theoretically was not a problem initially as Newsies Papermill run was originally only meant to be a proof of concept for regional licensing and scheduled to run from September of 2011 through mid October of 2011, with Bonnie & Clyde beginning previews at the Schoenfeld on November 4, 2011. Due to this as far as I am aware there weren't Broadway transfer stipulations in any of the Papermill contracts, which if things had gone as planned would not of been an issue.
It became an issue though when Newsies run at Papermill was a massive success with immediate speculation and clamoring for a quick transfer to Broadway, but unfortunately the shows lead was already under contract and about to begin an open ended run Bonnie & Clyde. Note although Bonnie & Clyde was a massive flop closing after less than a month of performances, going into the season all signs pointed to it being a big hit, meaning that the Jeremy Jordan likely wouldn't be available for a Broadway transfer of Newsies if Disney wanted to ride the buzz and pent up demand from the Papermill production to a quick Broadway transfer. As such there was rampant speculation when Disney did announce on November 15, 2011 that Newsies would transfer to Broadway for a limited run at the Nederlander from 3/15/12-6/10/12, as to who would star. There were allegedly behind the scenes discussions of Disney offering to buy Jordan out of his Bonnie & Clyde contract for the run, which he allegedly refused. The kernel of truth that those discussions likely happens caused some to believe/start spreading the rumor that Bonnie & Clyde only closed less than a month of performances because Disney paid off its producers to make Jordan available for Newsies Spring opening...which is obviously didn't happen.
Then even though Bonnie & Clyde did end up closing after at the end of 2011, meaning Jordan would be available for the Newsies transfer to the Nederlander 3 months later, that didn't mean Jordan was automatically going to do the transfer, as there was no deal in place. Remember over the course of the Fall 2011 Jordan went from just being the replacement Alternate for Tony in West Side Story and replacement swing in Rock of Ages, to Broadways next big leading man with back to back glowing reviews for his performances in both Newsies and Bonnie & Clyde. So Jordan and his team wanted to negotiate a new and likely significantly more costly contract if he were to sign onto the Broadway run of Newsies, which they were able to do because there were no Broadway transfer stipulations in the Papermill contract, as it was meant to be a one and done production. The negotiations were very intense and a headache for all involved, as both sides played hardball. Thus to avoid the negotiation nightmares and the large upcharge they likely had to pay to secure Jordan for the Broadway run, I would have to assume that since then Disney has added some sort of pay scale stipulation for a possible Broadway transfer to all future principal contracts of any of regional productions for musicals they are developing.
Updated On: 2/10/23 at 02:50 PM