Just got back from NYC. For filling such big shoes, Gerard really did a wonderful job. His singing was great, and he had a lot of excitement (or was really nervous?) I really enjoyed his performance, and I thought there was a lot of energy at Saturday evening's performance. He was having a good time. Ken, on the other hand, not my favorite, while Matt needs to have my children.
Gerard was honestly as good as all the Guilty Ones are saying, coming from someone who likes the show, but doesn't absolutely love it.
Updated On: 8/25/07 at 09:50 PM
I'm just curious if the same people who liked Gerard as Hanschen are the ones saying he was a great Moritz. Or if anyone concedes that he's a bad Hanschen but feels his talents were more suited to Moritz.
Mostly, I just stubbornly can't accept the overwhelmingly positive reviews. I must be biased.
Well, I'd say that out of all the roles Gerard has gone on for, his Hanschen is my least favorite. Thought I've never seen that...legally. I've seen his Moritz and Georg and found both to be absolutley amazing. His Georg is miles better than Skylar's is. So yes, I'd say that his Hanschen is just an overall weak spot for him.
After seeing how well Gerard did (and how well received his performance was) I hope there's a chance that he could be tapped to take over the role whenever Johnny G. Jr. goes off to make his next career step. I love Johnny and he's definitely made the role, but Gerard could handle it...
To SarahNYC : Gerard would love to take over the role, as a matter of fact, we did have a conversation about that subject. But he realizes that he was hired as a swing.And it is easier to find a performer to play Mortiz, then to train someone as a swing. However, word is out that Michael Mayer the director, was very impressed. So who knows what can or may happen. Either wasy, Gerard is a terrifc person and very talented and deserves whatever may come his way.
If Gallagher doesn't renew in November(I'm seeing the show over Christmas vacation) I wouldn't mind seeing Gerard with all the good things I've heard about him.
wait Gerard went on again? wasn't he supposed to alternate the role of Moritz with another actor when Gallagher is out? (I forgot specifically who the other actor is)
I was there too! It was my first broadway show and I was on the stage next to Gidieon and Jon b. wright!!It was awesome! I loved Gerard and I'm totally obsessed with Matt Doyle now! P.S. I'm so confused as to which guys are gay and which aren't. Rob Cavaney, the older guy in the ensemble that performance, told me that Gideion "plays for the other team", but I'm really confused about Jonathan Groff and Matt.
I saw Ken Marks as the Adult Men at the Actors Fund performance and he was absolutely horrendous. The scene between Moritz and his father, which, between Spinella and Gallagher, is one of the most chilling scenes in the show, was an absolute joke, and it completely threw off the main reasoning for why Moritz *spoiler* commits suicide. I agree that there are thousands of middle-aged actors in New York who could match Spinella's brilliance. What made them choose this guy, who looks and acts like Mr. Magoo?
"Winning a Tony this year is like winning Best Attendance in third grade: no one will care but the winner and their mom."
-Kad
"I have also met him in person, and I find him to be quite funny actually. Arrogant and often misinformed, but still funny."
-bjh2114 (on Michael Riedel)
Saw the matinee today. I agree that Gerard was great, but I don't think he matched Jonathan Groff well. He looks much younger than Jonathan. Actually, Gerard looks the age he's supposed to be playing. I think he'd do really well if he were to take over the role once John Gallagher, Jr. leaves. But we'll see about that.
I didn't think Ken Marks was horrendous, but I sorely missed Stephen Spinella. He was a definite standout for me. Stephen's scene with John Gallagher is just brilliant. And his breakdown in "Left Behind" is yet to be matched. Is Stephen gone for good?
I'm so confused as to which guys are gay and which aren't.
Yes, Gideon is openly gay, as is Stephen Spinella. The guys are pretty young and still sort of finding themselves, so a lot of them are of unknown orientation and/or have not really come out yet. Skylar is of course dating Lauren, but who really knows. Gerard is straight I think (surprised me....I thought he was flirting with me once). Pretty sure J. Gallagher is straight. Another that you asked about is pretty obviously gay (duh) but is quiet about it. And I know yet antoher who is still sort of coming out.
It's not really our business to out anyone (although of course it's fun to gossip), but if any of them are confused or closeted, I'd think this show would help them along. Its message, after all, is about openness and truth. I hope they all find that, gay or straight.
God, I hope not. Does anyone know why he's taking over a month of vacation?
"Winning a Tony this year is like winning Best Attendance in third grade: no one will care but the winner and their mom."
-Kad
"I have also met him in person, and I find him to be quite funny actually. Arrogant and often misinformed, but still funny."
-bjh2114 (on Michael Riedel)