Charley Kringas Inc said: "Busy week of fabulous OBCs:
Roar of the Greasepaint
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue
Lolita My Love (Nickerson tryout)
Merrily (1st preview)
Love Life
A Letter To Queen Victoria
Allegro
Follies
And then I would cap it with the full 24-Decade History of Popular Music, which would probably kill me and that would honestly be my preferred way to go."
I gotta say you have an interesting list. But I have some comments:
-- I saw A Letter to Queen Victoria at what is now the August Wilson theatre a thousand years ago, and it may have been the single most annoying evening I have spent in the theatre. Boredom set in 3 minutes into the show and never left. Be careful what you wish for.
-- I also saw 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue at the then Mark Hellinger 35ish years ago, and it was a complete mess. Despite the horrible production, it was clear that Patricia Routledge was a magical performer (unfortunately, her three ventures on Broadway (that I am aware of) were all massive failures and she stopped coming over, which was a real loss for Broadway.She was one fo the rare handful of stage performers who you just know is special. She was special in this and Darling of the Day,which I loved; but this was a mess, except for her. I understand the score is actually excellent, and you could appreciate the some of the songs were standouts on first hearing / seeing, but it was a boring mess.
-- I saw Marat / Sade, but was too young to appreciate it at the time. I remember actually being a little scared watching it (I was about 16) because it was just so intense and the cast was so believable. I did not include this on my list, but it would be an interesting re-visit at a (too-)much more mature age.
-- I also saw Merrily in previews, not the first one, and violently hated it. It was one of those super-rare (unique?) cases where the huge portion of blame rested at Harold Prince's feet. His approach to the production was a major failure (age of the cast, cast wearing T-Shirts that said what they were (which you couldn't read from the 5th row, and I was in the cheap seats (which were actually cheap). The Maria Freidman production that I saw in Boston was a revelation, although there was still a coldness through much of the show (because Franklin Shepherd was an iceman). Only in the last scene, which was brilliant, did his innocence and warmth come through, which was clearly intentional, right, but still meant that the show was cold. But I loved it.
-- I saw Roar of the Greasepaint from the cheap seats in the Shubert theatre somewhere in the mid-to-late 60s. I remember not fully understanding it, but loving it because the score was great on first listening, and Ritchard (particularly) and Newley were terrific. It was essentially a 2 man show, with a small cast backing them up. It had a great show-stopper, Where Would You Be Without Me, a number of terrific songs, including Feeling Good, which almost felt like filler at the time (probably because, as I remember there many years ago, the character who sang the role (played by Gilbert Price) sort-of came from no-where)...now it is a classic, then it seemed like filler. IT would indeed be very interesting to see it again. (Though it was not the hit that Stop the World, I wasn't to Get Off Was, I enjoyed it much better, although I will acknowledge that I saw filmed version, which can never capture alive performance.
-- I saw Follies multiple times, and still consider it to be the single greatest evening I have spent in the theatre. The perfect production of a show that has always been flawed.