Another review:
"I was at an industry screening last night, and I wept. The film is beautiful, the music is so lush and gorgeous. All of the actors are spot-on. The few changes to the script are mainly there to streamline the story for timing. At a few points they do seem to over-explain things that were left implicit in the stage show, but that didn't bother me too much.
A couple of things I really liked about the adaptation:
1. The use of daylight.
Stage productions seem to exist only in a dark, overgrown, nighttime woods, and when you think about it, they are there for three days straight. Some of it will take place during the daytime, and Marshall used this wisely for some of the lighter scenes ("Agony," for example) which also gave us some lovely landscape shots. He let night fall when scenes became more ominous.
2. Giving The Witch a deadline
Since I saw the Central Park revival, in which Donna Murphy appeared to get older as the first act wore on, I realized that as written The Witch's three-midnight deadline for the Baker and his Wife is rather arbitrary. Why now and why only three days? Why didn't she come to them sooner and give them as long as it took? The revival showed that it had little to do with them and everything to do with her. She could lift the curse on them whenever she wanted, but she had little time to lift the curse on herself, which really raised the stakes. Similarly, the movie gives them three midnights before [the blue moon that rises every hundred years, and the spell can only be reversed then] so The Witch has her own deadline to worry about.
Also, I liked how the combined scenes and in some places let action speak louder than words to move the story along. It allowed the songs to breathe more and savor the moment, since the momentum of the plot was moving so strongly.
And, for those who are worried, the only ways in which the story has been made more family friendly is in how it's shown. We don't see a toe or heel drop to the floor, we don't see the Baker's Wife fall from the cliff, we don't see Rapunzel's Prince with blood dripping from his eyes, it's all done artistically. But all of that is still there, and the impact is the same.
And Meryl's "Last Midnight" is a tour de force."
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2180411/board/thread/237275934
Updated On: 11/26/14 at 12:58 PM