I'm a dissenter here about Carney, whose vocals I found stirring and soulful. Just listened to "Wait for Me" on a playlist last night and remembered how touching his plangent rendition was in the Kerr in early August. I saw Fisher his last week in Sweeney, and his light pop instrument, though probably competent amid lesser voices in a different company, just barely served with the current cast. I can't imagine the first act of Hadestown's crescendo working without a vocal performance like Carney's. Whatever anyone thinks of his work, he nails the music. And to me, the show is all music.
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling