I hate to be the skeptical one, because I thought Tick… Tick… BOOM! was an unexpectedly fantastic movie musical so I refuse to doubt Lin-Manuel Miranda’s ability to bring out the best of the material. And I love that he’s directing a Dave Malloy musical.
But I cannot fathom how this show works as a film, even if I can imagine the ways a director can open up the musical.
I was listening to the score again last night, and I was reminded of the fact that most of the songs last forever, and even though it sounds like Malloy, he’s not at his most tuneful here. I realize that’s part of the point, and I enjoyed the show when I saw it at the Berkeley Rep.
So we’ll see. I like the idea of Miranda directing this show when he could be doing anything else and attracting an interesting cast.