I returned to the Hudson last Wednesday night through TDF for one of the performances without Daniel Radcliffe. Figured I'd post a little report for anyone considering going to a no-Radcliffe performance when it's more affordable.
Koray Tarhan was on for Charley and I enjoyed his performance! He reads as visibly younger than the other two, so he reads more like Frank's younger brother who eventually realizes his pal's not all he's cracked up to be. Because of that dynamic, he was stronger in act two. Now, If you’re only going to see Merrily once I’d see Radcliffe if you can since it’s hard to match his precision, especially in Franklin Shepard Inc., and spot-on comic timing. The usual trio is magic together. But even if you miss Radcliffe, you’re still seeing a top-drawer, well-directed Merrily with outstanding performances.
I haven’t posted my thoughts about the show on here before—and I won't go on, since this been open for months and y'all know it's good already—but I love this production. Maria Friedman’s Huntington production was my first exposure to Merrily and I previously saw the NY iteration at NYTW and the first Broadway preview. I’d gladly see this production again and again if it wasn’t as pricey as it is. Merrily has such high rewatch value for me since it's interesting to focus on different relationships and dynamics each time. This time I focused more on the Frank and Mary relationship and god, Jonathan Groff and Lindsay Mendez are just so good. I'd be overjoyed to see them win Tonys for this. Mendez’s Mary really is the beating heart of this show, the glue friend at the center of the trio, and wow does she sing the hell out of Now You Know. Pure brass. And I could rave about Groff’s performance, which still feels fresh and layered. He may have even gotten better, and he was already giving a must-see performance. I can’t imagine a better Frank.
Well worth a return trip if it pops up on TDF again! And even if it doesn't. It's nice to take a break from the busy spring season and revisit an old friend.