i saw the show tonight for the first time.
I found parts of it very boring, to be honest, mostly a series of incredibly choreographed performance numbers strung together by painful dialogue that the actors seemed to want to rush through. the structure made no sense- its "Satine's story" but Christian tells it but they need to first excite us with a big opening number before he sets the mood- its all over the place.
BUT that grumpiness aside, it does a bangup job doing what it wants to do which is to electrify audiences with big song and dance. there needs to be a Tony award for Best Ensemble, or Best Dancers, because to nominate/award the choreographer is one thing, but the incredible work from this team deserves its own recognition.
I'm no writer but why give every single ounce of wit/intelligence to ONE character? Sahr Ngaujah was hilarious and incredibly moving at every turn. Standout, if you ask me.
Tveit doesn't get enough love here. I find it hard to blame him for how underwritten/dull his role is, and I'm hard pressed to think of any other leading man who could do what he does vocally with such ease. And when the text gives him the opportunity, he makes the most of it- ie the Roxanne/Crazy/Rolling portion of the show.
I never saw Karen Olivo in this role, but Mendoza seems to be vocally mimicking her a bit (which I don't love, because I am admittedly not a big fan of Olivo's voice). Still, she can certainly sing the role (she made the Elephant Love Medley her own) and she nails the performance overall. There was snickering at the start of Firework (i assume there often is because its such a stupid song) but she turned it around beautifully and I semi-bought that that she and Tveit fell in love in the span of 90 seconds. I wouldn't describe them as having red-hot chemistry or sexual heat, but more like clueless puppy love. She's warm and likeable. And incredibly gorgeous.
i imagine this show will run for a long while, its a hard-working crowd pleaser. and it seems like its in great shape.