Mary Poppins Reviews — Page 3
Posted: 11/17/06 at 2:09am
"Unveiled yesterday at the New Amsterdam Theatre, the musical "Mary Poppins" resembles a vast, elaborate clockwork toy of yesteryear. It's festooned with an array of bells, whistles and cute mechanical figures.
Whether kids will be thrilled by such a vintage gadget is debatable. Adults are likely to mix fond smiles with yawns. While the energetic Sherman Brothers parts of the score are enjoyable, the cluttered musical isn't as wonderful as hoped.
A patchy merger between P.L. Travers' whimsical stories about a magical English nanny and the beloved 1964 Disney movie musical derived from them, "Mary Poppins" features a colorful parade of upbeat song-and-dance sequences, literally tons of handsome scenery and an agreeable company.
True enchantment appears to be in short supply, however.
__________________________________________________________________
Certainly a more fulfilling experience than the vacuous "Tarzan," this over-stuffed version of "Mary Poppins" strives very hard to satisfy viewers. Sometimes it succeeds. But for a show about enchantment in everyday life, isn't magic supposed to seem effortless? "
http://www.nj.com/entertainment/ledger/index.ssf?/base/entertainment-0/1163743846307060.xml&coll=1
Posted: 11/17/06 at 2:13am
Posted: 11/17/06 at 2:31am
Posted: 11/17/06 at 2:35am
Posted: 11/17/06 at 2:38am
And just so there's no debate, I am kidding and being VERY sarcastic.
Posted: 11/17/06 at 2:45am
Posted: 11/17/06 at 2:47am
Posted: 11/17/06 at 2:49am
Posted: 11/17/06 at 3:14am
"The last train out of any station will not be full of nice guys." - Dr. Hunter S. Thompson
"I wash my face, then drink beer, then I weep. Say a prayer and induce insincere self-abuse, till I'm fast asleep"- In Trousers
Posted: 11/17/06 at 3:16am
"If a few mechanical marvels are enough for you (or your little ones), then the charms of this highly anticipated adaptation of the 1964 movie musical will not feel too fleeting or sporadic. But anyone hoping that this show -- staged by director Richard Eyre and choreographer Matthew Bourne -- would provide much in the way of robust musical pleasure or emotional sustenance is likely to find it a wee bit of a letdown.
All the va-va-va-voom is contained here in the environment created by designer Bob Crowley. The new songs by George Stiles and Anthony Drewe that supplement the Poppins standards by the Sherman brothers, Richard M. and Robert B., are fairly flaccid. In other words, what this "Mary Poppins" primarily has going for it is sets appeal.
_______________________________________________________________
A bigger problem has to do with the portrayal of Mary herself. It's clear that Mary, as drawn in the stories of P.L. Travers, was never meant to be as saccharine as "A Spoonful of Sugar" makes her out. In this incarnation, however, she's neither sweet nor sour: She has almost no personality at all. In the placid mien and clipped vowels of Ashley Brown, Mary seems not so much a calming influence as she does an automaton. She walks and talks with a robotic briskness.
Brown, possessed of a fine voice, wages an uphill battle with the memory of Julie Andrews, who had the ability to radiate warmth as well as efficiency. This new recruit to the role conveys only the competent dimension."
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/11/16/AR2006111601844.html
Posted: 11/17/06 at 3:20am
LOL!
I certainly found Mary Poppins to be a very theme-park rendition of the story. I believe--like one of the reviews mentioned--that the actors seem so mechanical on stage, so easy to replace that even troupers of the like of Jenkins and Luker can't save the evening for me, at least. I know 90% of Broadway audiences disagree and I am OK with that. As for the Best Musical Tony Award, I *HIGHLY* doubt that with Grey Gardens, Curtains and Spring Awakening running it will hace a chance; as a matter of fact, if Legally Blonde is any good, Mary Poppins might not even be nominated.
Posted: 11/17/06 at 3:27am
what would it take to get this talented critic back to NY? he could easily replace whoever the Daily News is using now. And he would be a nice break from Isherwood, who has his old job.
"The last train out of any station will not be full of nice guys." - Dr. Hunter S. Thompson
"I wash my face, then drink beer, then I weep. Say a prayer and induce insincere self-abuse, till I'm fast asleep"- In Trousers
Posted: 11/17/06 at 4:11am
--------------------------------
November 17, 2006 -- LOVELY! With her carpetbag, a parrot-headed umbrella for airy transport and the rare ability to slide up banisters, the inimitable heroine of "Mary Poppins" put down and took off at the New Amsterdam last night, courtesy of Cameron Mackintosh, Walt Disney and the original author, P.L. Travers.
"Mary Poppins" was fine as a Disney movie and is even better as this Broadway musical, imported sound and whole from London's West End. Let's play cute and call it - and the cast led by Ashley Brown, Gavin Lee, Daniel Jenkins and Rebecca Luker - supercalifragilisticexpialidocious. Or words to that effect.
This story - of a supernanny who literally descends upon the unruly, unhappy Banks family on 17 Cherry Tree Lane, somewhere in Edwardian London, proceeds to restore order and then just as literally takes off into the heavens - has its own built-in magic.
And it's a magic that the musical, with its urbane and knowing book by Julian Fellowes, cleverly evokes in a manner a little darker, more mysterious and a good deal more authentic to the novel than the overly jolly movie version.
Most of the music, of course, is taken from the film's original score by Richard M. Sherman and Robert B. Sherman, so you probably go in humming the tunes. But the new and amiable songs by George Stiles and Anthony Drewe make a decent fit, and the whole patchwork, orchestrated by William David Brohn, has just that right Broadway belt and lilt.
What makes Mackintosh currently the best producer on Broadway and the West End is his creative touch and the manner in which he picks his collaborators, places them on the same page, and makes sure they stay there.
"Mary Poppins" looks and sounds complete - a perfectly engineered piece of musical theater.
The staging by Richard Eyre and co-director Matthew Bourne and choreography (Bourne and Stephen Mear) seem seamless, although perhaps Bourne, with a set of smoothly energized and imaginative dance numbers, deserves the most laurels.
--------------------------------
NY Post Review
"The last train out of any station will not be full of nice guys." - Dr. Hunter S. Thompson
"I wash my face, then drink beer, then I weep. Say a prayer and induce insincere self-abuse, till I'm fast asleep"- In Trousers
Updated On: 11/17/06 at 04:11 AM
Posted: 11/17/06 at 4:34am
"The last train out of any station will not be full of nice guys." - Dr. Hunter S. Thompson
"I wash my face, then drink beer, then I weep. Say a prayer and induce insincere self-abuse, till I'm fast asleep"- In Trousers
Posted: 11/17/06 at 4:37am
And I hope the cast got to do SOME partying tonight.
Posted: 11/17/06 at 6:34am
Posted: 11/17/06 at 6:54am
But I respect all critics opinions, nonetheless.
Posted: 11/17/06 at 7:21am
The only review that will really matter is ROSIES>>>>>>
Posted: 11/17/06 at 9:22am
https://www.nycriticscorner.broadwayworld.com/marypoppins.htm
Posted: 11/17/06 at 9:35am
It's depressing NOT liking a show. I go in, having spent my money (well, unless it's a comp), and I'm hoping each time to have an enjoyable and hopefully satisfying experience. But that doesn't always happen.
And for those of you who think that we're symbolically "crapping on your car" for not liking a show... you really need to grow up.
It's an opinion... nothing more... but nothing less. It counts only as much as your own.
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
Posted: 11/17/06 at 9:55am
Posted: 11/17/06 at 10:04am
he hated DROWSY CHAPERONE too!
BroadwayWorld TV