Dan Stevens and Luke Evans look right for the parts for which they were cast, specifically the prince (not as the beast, of course
) and Gaston, but they don't seem to have sung in their other roles, according to IMDb. I hope they have decent voices.
I saw a SNL spoof of BATB with Gerard Butler as the beast, Bill Hader as Lumiere, Bobby Moynihan as the clock, and Kristin Wiig as Belle. It was hilarious, and Bill Hader was fantastic.
I would have liked to see the beast done by a baritone or bass, with the prince a tenor. Norm Lewis and James Barbour would have been perfect as the beast, with Ramin Karimloo as the prince. I like the idea of NPH or Bill Hader as Lumiere. Ewan McGregor is certainly a big name, but I wonder if he was really the right choice for Lumiere; does he have any singing or comedic acting experience?
As for Gaston, I can think of a whole bunch of handsome Broadway stars, of varying ages, who could have played the role. I've never seen Peter Gallagher live, but he strikes me as the "right type." So do Hugh Panaro, Will Swenson, and once more, Lewis and Barbour, who may have felt a sense of deja vu. (I doubt I'm the only one who has noticed the similarities between BATB and POTO). Among movie stars, Gerard Butler and Hugh Jackman have the looks, have experience in film musicals, and have comedic talent. I also saw a young man on tour named Tim Rogan whose interpretation of Gaston blew the audience away. Any one of them would have been great.
Audrey
Audrey, the Phantom Phanatic, who nonetheless would rather be Jean Valjean, who knew how to make lemonade out of lemons.