Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Official "Beauty & the Beast" Film Adaptation Thread — Page 60

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1476

Official

"Unrequited love is an offensive stereotype? I haven't seen the movie, but from all reports the gay subtext is barely even noticeable. What made it offensive or stereotypical?"

It's not about "unrequited love." In the movie, LeFou is presented as a slimy little sidekick to Gaston, with actual smirking sexual designs on him, and he's a vile little collaborator in Gaston's schemes -- it's a tasteless throwback to 1970s Gay Villain schlock. It doesn't even have the comparative class of Philip Seymour Hoffman's character in BOOGIE NIGHTS -- Le Fou can't summon the sympathy, despite a last minute change of heart that comes too late to really amount to anything at all.


"If they can get you asking the wrong questions, they don't have to worry about the answers." Thomas Pynchon, GRAVITY'S RAINBOW "Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away." Philip K. Dick My blog: http://www.roscoewrites.blogspot.com/
#1477

Official

Roscoe: "Unrequited love is an offensive stereotype? I haven't seen the movie, but from all reports the gay subtext is barely even noticeable. What made it offensive or stereotypical?"

It's not about "unrequited love." In the movie, LeFou is presented as a slimy little sidekick to Gaston, with actual smirking sexual designs on him, and he's a vile little collaborator in Gaston's schemes -- it's a tasteless throwback to 1970s Gay Villain schlock. It doesn't even have the comparative class of Philip Seymour Hoffman's character in BOOGIE NIGHTS -- Le Fou can't summon the sympathy, despite a last minute change of heart that comes too late to really amount to anything at all.




^ see I don't agree with that. His change of heart did not come too late. He was constantly protesting Gaston's stupid things (like leaving Maurice out to die, and then lying for him later). Those things did not happen near the end of Le Fou's character. He became slowly disillusioned. Changing your heart is not an easy "I just saw the real him" moment kind of thing, and I'm glad they didn't treat it like that. Yes, the innuendos were grossly exaggerated, but there's nothing a gay character can do which will be universally acceptable. Let's choose our fights wisely. I'm more than happy to own that character, choices and all, as a part of my community.


I saw the movie last night finally, and my only complaint is that the very last scene when Le Fou dances with a guy is less than a second long. You blink and it's gone. I wanted it to be a real moment so it doesn't seem accidental or even comical.


Caption: Every so often there was a rare moment of perfect balance when I soared above him.
#1478

Official

Valentina3 said: "see I don't agree with that. His change of heart did not come too late. He was constantly protesting Gaston's stupid things (like leaving Maurice out to die, and then lying for him later). Those things did not happen near the end of Le Fou's character. He became slowly disillusioned. Changing your heart is not an easy "I just saw the real him" moment kind of thing, and I'm glad they didn't treat it like that. Yes, the innuendos were grossly exaggerated, but there's nothing a gay character can do which will be universally acceptable. Let's choose our fights wisely. I'm more than happy to own that character, choices and all, as a part of my community."

Looks like we disagree. Glad you can own such a vile little beast as part of your community. For me, it was the exact opposite. His "change of heart" came off more as a bogus plot contrivance, and he never, as far as I remember, actually does anything at all to make up for his wrongdoing. LeFou, as presented onscreen, is the equivalent of a Log Cabin Republican who has just admitted that maybe voting for Trump wasn't such a hot idea -- his realization has come too late to be of any use to anyone at all, and he's responsible for too much damage to be so easily forgiven. To hell with LeFou.


"If they can get you asking the wrong questions, they don't have to worry about the answers." Thomas Pynchon, GRAVITY'S RAINBOW "Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away." Philip K. Dick My blog: http://www.roscoewrites.blogspot.com/

Updated On: 3/31/17 at 12:25 PM

#1479

Official Beauty and the Beast movie

just saw it tonight

great adaptation and loved the new songs...

did miss one of my favorite songs If I cant Love her

Josh Gad is just plain wonderful in his sidekick roles!!!!

more musical movies, please!

#1480

Official Beauty and the Beast movie

Enjoyed the movie but I missed "if I can't love her" "human again" and "me." I was happy to see (hear) Audra bc I had no idea she would be in the movie. Certainly the best singing voice there. Overall I liked the new songs but missed a few of the originals. Maybe they will revive the musical or at least do a touring production with a mix of the old and new songs.

#1481

Official Beauty and the Beast movie

Threads are so much nicer without cheap little shills coming in. God bless the block function.


"If they can get you asking the wrong questions, they don't have to worry about the answers." Thomas Pynchon, GRAVITY'S RAINBOW "Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away." Philip K. Dick My blog: http://www.roscoewrites.blogspot.com/
#1482

Official Beauty and the Beast movie

Dave28282 said: "Ps. A special shout-out to the fishing lady singing in the intro of The Mob song. She really went for it."

I think she wandered over from playing one of the factory workers/poor people in "Les MIserables."

#1483

Official Beauty and the Beast movie

Scarywarhol said: "I'm listening to these new numbers. Tim Rice has been on autopilot for years, and was certainly never half as good as Ashman, but I'm still surprised. Good LORD, are these embarrassing lyrics! It's a joke to put them next to the original songs."

I felt pretty much the same way. "Evermore" was really generic, but the absolute WORST was in the reprise to 'Beauty and the Beast' where Emma Thompson actually sings the lines "Nature points the way/Nothing left to say/Beauty and the Beast."

Seriously? "Nothing left to say"???? You're wrapping up a story about a cursed prince discovering love and his own humanity and unjudgmental love and all that and you actually wrote a line that basically says, "I give up, I got nothin', let's just end this song right here!"

I mean, *I* could have come up with 20 better lines on the spot, and I don't even write musical lyrics!

The absolute worst. Lazy, terrible writing. Yech.

#1484

Official Beauty and the Beast movie

sarahb22 said: "Seriously? "Nothing left to say"???? You're wrapping up a story about a cursed prince discovering love and his own humanity and unjudgmental love and all that and you actually wrote a line that basically says, "I give up, I got nothin', let's just end this song right here!"

I mean, *I* could have come up with 20 better lines on the spot, and I don't even write musical lyrics!

The absolute worst. Lazy, terrible writing. Yech."




Ok, let's hear some of them ... you don't need to post 20 of them ... just a couple ... and then we'll see if the other board members think that they should have hired you instead of Tim Rice!

#1485

Official Beauty and the Beast movie

sarahb22 said: "Scarywarhol said: "I'm listening to these new numbers. Tim Rice has been on autopilot for years, and was certainly never half as good as Ashman, but I'm still surprised. Good LORD, are these embarrassing lyrics! It's a joke to put them next to the original songs."

I felt pretty much the same way. "Evermore" was really generic, but the absolute WORST was in the reprise to 'Beauty and the Beast' where Emma Thompson actually sings the lines "Nature points the way/Nothing left to say/Beauty and the Beast."

Seriously? "Nothing left to say"???? You're wrapping up a story about a cursed prince discovering love and his own humanity and unjudgmental love and all that and you actually wrote a line that basically says, "I give up, I got nothin', let's just end this song right here!"

I mean, *I* could have come up with 20 better lines on the spot, and I don't even write musical lyrics!

The absolute worst. Lazy, terrible writing. Yech."


Well I'm sorry to be the bearer of bad news but those are actually Howard Ashman lyrics that never made the original movie. Though were he alive today he may well have kept them being aired here too. I suspect he'd have quite a few opinions on the direction/performances/screenplay tbh...

Restored Howard Ashman lyrics in the "live action" Beauty and the Beast

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $67