BEAUTY AND THE BEAST -- dear God.
Believe it or not, I want to love every movie I see. Really, truly. I don't ask for much, I don't think -- I'll forgive a whole lot as long as I don't feel that my intelligence is being insulted 24 frames a second for two hours. Bill Condon's CGI with humans version of Disney's BEAUTY AND THE BEAST can't manage that basic requirement. I'm in something of a state of shock here -- how could they have ****ed this up this badly?
So the good stuff. Luke Evans, as the merry macho chauvinist ****head Gaston, is actually pretty good. He's charming and funny and mean as ****, and he's so much fun that I was getting disappointed when Gaston's true villainous colors start to emerge. Emma Watson as Belle plays her role well enough, despite a strange stiffness in her upper body that made me wonder if she'd suffered some serious back injury right before production. Her singing is perfectly adequate for contemporary live action big budget movie musical -- she doesn't disgrace herself, which is more than can be said for others in other films. She's the least of the movie's problems.
OK, the bad stuff. Where to begin. I feel like it would take a vast tome of Tolstoyan dimensions to number every gross offense against basic movie-going decency committed by this piece of dreck. Here are some of the more prominent horrors.
1. The criminal waste of an overall pretty good cast. Director Bill Condon had the good sense to hire some great people in front of his camera and to pose for his motion-capture technology. Stalwarts like Ewan McGregor as Lumiere, Ian McKellen as Cogsworth the talking clock, Kevin Kline as Belle's father. Alas, they're all pretty dreadful. McGregor's Lumiere speaks with a nearly impenetrable French accent that renders his one big song, the heavily CGI'd Be Our Guest, simply unintelligible (check out the vocal by Jerry Orbach in the original for a performance that actually seems to acknowledge that those sounds are supposed to be words that actually, you know, have meanings). McKellen and Kline do the easiest hackwork of their careers -- Kline in particular seems more than a little embarrassed by the whole enterprise. And Condon went to the trouble of casting Audra McDonald, one of the great artists currently occupying space above ground, and reduces her to a Joanne Whorley impression.
2. The Beast. I just can't imagine what on earth possessed them to put Dan Stevens in the movie in the first place, unless it was the notion that they'd get some crossover PBS fans just dying to get even a heavily CGI-ed glimpse of their long-lamented Downton Abbey dreamboat. He's a pretty low-key actor, to put it politely, but his low-key performance is buried under the frankly bargain-basement CGI used to turn him into the Beast. He smiles and frowns and glowers and grimaces on cue, but there's just no real life there, no magic to animate the ones and zeroes into something interesting or memorable. Think of Andy Serkis and Peter Jackson's accomplishment with Gollum in the Middle Earth movies, and you'll get an idea of what isn't happening here. It's a colossal failure, weirdly apparent than during the resolutely un-miraculous transformation from Beast to Prince. Whatever else can be said of the Beast, he's broad-shouldered narrow-waisted and conspicuously well-muscled, and there's nothing more ridiculous than the way he dwindles into that chinless little twerp embodied by Dan Stevens wearing what looks like one of Brad Pitt's leftover wigs from that vampire movie. Garbo is supposed to have exclaimed, at the end of the Cocteau film of the story when the Beast turns into a rather effete Jean Gabin, "Give me back my Beast!" Garbo today would be saying, "Give me back my Beast's motion-capture body double!" Which brings us to:
3. The CGI. Cheap. Cheesy. To be fair, the animated furniture is pretty well done -- there's a walking piano and a pugilistic hatstand that I kinda dug on. But too much of it calls too much attention to itself as being CGI, in that "every shot has to be a showstopper" kind of way, where a character hits a high note at the end of a song and is of course standing at a window so the camera can pull out through the window and go all the way back so we can see the whole landscape to show off how much money they spent on the CGI. There's just no real flavor to it -- look folks, here's a big castle, here's a sunset, here's a forest with snow, here's a ballroom. For all the display on display, it's just ones and zeroes.
4. Holes in the story --
So the movie begins with the pre-Beast Prince refusing charity to a homeless person who turns out to be a Very Powerful Magical Person, and who then curses the Beast for having no love in his heart for not giving her shelter, and all that. Well, okay, putting aside for now the fact that it turns out that the VPMP actually lives in the woods under a fallen tree anyway, it has to be pointed out that this same VPMP, who starts the story going by Punishing Those With No Love In Their Hearts, is shown standing not five feet away from the film's real villain, Gaston, as he demonstrates Trumpian levels of brutality and hate-mongering -- and she does exactly nothing. Nada. Zip zero zilch. WTF? And remember, this character doesn't appear in the original animated film outside the opening plot exposition -- her reappearance later was added for this version, which means that Condon & Co. have actually added a major plot hole to a story that didn't have one.
And there's more -- the cynicism of the whole enterprise, in taking a movie and remaking it purely for the cash, and making such a hash of the whole thing. And the cynicism extends to Disney's trumpeting of the its First Gay Character, clearly a PR stunt to provoke religious boycotts of the film over it's Gay Character, which lets us all hate on bigots (fine by me, of course) but also deflects criticism from the frankly offensive Gay Villain sidekick stereotype, where there's a pathetic queer in love with an out of his league straight hunk.
"If they can get you asking the wrong questions, they don't have to worry about the answers." Thomas Pynchon, GRAVITY'S RAINBOW
"Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away." Philip K. Dick
My blog: http://www.roscoewrites.blogspot.com/