Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Official "Beauty & the Beast" Film Adaptation Thread — Page 59

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1451

Yeah, it's not really apples and oranges here, it's more like an apple that people loved and paid to eat, and then another apple designed to make you think fondly of how much you liked that old apple, and genetically engineered to be a bigger apple, and with some glitter dusted on it in the grocery display.

#1452

I found the film to be incredibly boring and uninspired. These live actions films just seem like a ploy for Disney to cash in (which they're doing easily). All of the acting and singing was fine, I just don't see why the need for the film; the animated film is superior in every way.

God bless, Audra Mcdonald.

#1453

I saw it today. Thought it was fine. It was the animated film for better or worse. But the scenery was beautiful, as well as the new orchestrations. I had some problems with the CGI, especially the Beast. He felt that he had no weight to him. I thought the majority of the performances were good. Yeah, this was definitely a re-hash of the animated film. And all the new plot elements did not contribute to anything towards the original story. I gotta say though, I really enjoyed the opening ball. It had this dark looming sense, like out of Neil Jordan's The Company of Wolves, but alas it fell into the disney film as soon as the enchantress came. For me this lies in the middle of the remakes and reimagines of disney animated fare. It's no nears as good Cinderella or Pete's Dragon, but it was waaaay better then Maleficent or Alice in Wonderland.

#1455

It was so good! Almost as good as the original. I wondered why they cut A Part of Your World, but I liked the newer songs, and I guess they wanted to make it different.



"

#1456

What gay thing did I miss?

Hi MC,

You joined "today"... so just FYI, Part Of Your World is Little Mermaid....


I Can Has Cheezburger With This?
#1457

What gay thing did I miss?

That article is so good!

"It’s nice to believe that anyone could open their mouths and sound like a princess. The truth, as with so many Hollywood fantasies, is much less appealing. If you really want to sell the myth, then the talent has to be superhuman—dub the voices, just as you fake stunts, apply makeup, and at this point, even transform the actors’ appearances. Commit to the fantasy. If we wanted reality, we wouldn’t be seeing a movie with a talking teapot."

This.

#1458

To Defend Ms Watson's performance for a moment, I think we all forget that Belle is not a princess known for her song. In actuality she is one of 3 princesses who do not actually have an iconic "I Want" song. These include Jasmine, whose song is actually the Duet A Whole New World with Aladdin, as she is not the protagonist. Add to that when Alladin was adapted for the stage I think they went through 2 or 3 different "I want" songs for her before settling on These Palace Walls. The other is Merida who doesn't sing.

Yes Belle has the Belle Reprise, which is 1 minute and 3 seconds of mostly spoken or softly song lyrics except for the following two lines "I want much more than this provincial life/ I want adventure in the great wide somewhere". If you actually listen to the original animated version or even the original Broadway version, its not so much Belle's vocals getting more powerful, as it is the orchestra swelling.

The lead vocal performance of Beauty and the Beast, has never actually been Belle's. In the original movie it was Lumiere and Mrs Potts, and in the Original Broadway adaptation it was Beast. Belle didn't even have a vocal moment outside of Belle in the Broadway adaptation until Toni Braxton joined the production and A Change in Me was added to the score.

Do I think Emma Watson's vocal capabilities are the reason why A Change in Me, was dropped from the live action adaptation? Partially I do, but it also would not work in the live action film, as it would come right after the film stopping Forever More, causing the movie to come to a stop for 2 big ballads.

In all honesty Watson is a fine Belle, and people need to stop confusing Belle with the vocal Powerhouse Princesses of Ariel (Part of Your World, Mulan (Reflection), Pocahontas (Colors of the Wind), Tiana (Almost There), Rapunzel (When Will my Life Begin), Anna (For the First Time in Forever), Elsa (Let it Go), Moana (How Far I'll Go), as Belle does not have a song that those pipes are need for.

#1459

Isn't it really a more feminist message if Belle isn't a powerhouse singer? Disney has set young girls up to believe they have to look a certain way and be musically gifted and that's the only way they are worthy of love. That's why so many young women have self-esteem issues. Why does the Disney princess have to be beautiful and talented while the guy can just be a hairy jerk? What are we telling our daughters? Maybe it's time to celebrate mediocrity.

#1460

I saw it yesterday and LOVED it! I thought the cast was great, and there isn't really much I'd consider changing. I'll definitely be heading back for another viewing.


"Was uns befreit, das muss stärker sein als wir es sind." -Tanz der Vampire
#1461

MaryCarey said: "Isn't it really a more feminist message if Belle isn't a powerhouse singer? Disney has set young girls up to believe they have to look a certain way and be musically gifted and that's the only way they are worthy of love. That's why so many young women have self-esteem issues. Why does the Disney princess have to be beautiful and talented while the guy can just be a hairy jerk? What are we telling our daughters? Maybe it's time to celebrate mediocrity. "

Ok, this is out of line. Not everybody is a moviestar for a reason. People love to see beautiful people and singers in movies because of the beauty. Why not having every neighbour from the street on the radio and in movies every day? Because we don't want to hear and see mediocrity.

#1462

MaryCarey said: "Isn't it really a more feminist message if Belle isn't a powerhouse singer? Disney has set young girls up to believe they have to look a certain way and be musically gifted and that's the only way they are worthy of love. That's why so many young women have self-esteem issues. Why does the Disney princess have to be beautiful and talented while the guy can just be a hairy jerk? What are we telling our daughters? Maybe it's time to celebrate mediocrity.

You are REACHING!

#1463


You are REACHING!





"

How so?

#1464

Audra enchanted me, I dunno if it was her characters look or her screen presence but she was so drawing and captivating. The musical numbers where all quite dull to be honest. Where was this amazing choreography we heard about for Be Our Guest, that was very small scale considering the hype. I liked Belle, Gaston and the Mob Song they were staged well and energetic.

Unfortunately every new song they added to the film were staged terribly and added absolutely nothing to the plot. The film works great as an homage though and some of it is magical. I like the furniture a lot better in this than the animated film and show.

#1465

Saw it tonight. Incompetent. Shockingly so.

#1466

Steve C. said: "
1] I saw it in IMAX 3D Experience and it really didn't play off of that technology well.



"

I saw it in IMAX 2D and I thought it was quite pleasing.


My father (AIDS) My sister (AIDS) My uncle and my cousin and her best friend (AIDS, AIDS, AIDS) The gays and the straights And the white and the spades
#1467

bdn223, in the Broadway score for B&TB Belle sang a song called "Home" shortly after being imprisoned.


"Contentment, it seems, simply happens. It appears accompanied by no bravos and no tears."
#1468

Official "Beauty & the Beast" Film Adaptation Thread

I saw it! I liked it! Thank goodness it was better than the endless, boring Cinderella remake. As feared, Emma Watson's singing wasn't the best, but I noticed it less and less as the film went on (possibly because Belle sings less in the later stages?) and got on board with her character anyway. Dan Stevens and the rest of the cast were great. I thought most of the plot additions 'justified themselves' by filling in a few minor plot holes from the animated version and

Click Here To Toggle Spoiler Content

contributing to Maurice's new Triton-esque character arc about letting Belle grow up.

It wasn't perfect, but a good time was had by all.

#1469

Official

Shameless bit of self promotion, I know, but I figured you guys might enjoy this:

https://youtu.be/F8oK8_-HYNw

(also, I've enjoyed reading every bit of this now 59 page thread over the last couple years; thanks for a fun ride)

#1470

Official

"Isn't it really a more feminist message if Belle isn't a powerhouse singer? Disney has set young girls up to believe they have to look a certain way and be musically gifted and that's the only way they are worthy of love. That's why so many young women have self-esteem issues. Why does the Disney princess have to be beautiful and talented while the guy can just be a hairy jerk? What are we telling our daughters? Maybe it's time to celebrate mediocrity.

I have the same expectation for the guy to be a good singer, too.


Jimmy, what are you doing here in the middle of the night? It's almost 9 PM!
#1471

Official

bdn223 said: "

The lead vocal performance of Beauty and the Beast, has never actually been Belle's. In the original movie it was Lumiere and Mrs Potts, and in the Original Broadway adaptation it was Beast. Belle didn't even have a vocal moment outside of Belle in the Broadway adaptation until Toni Braxton joined the production and A Change in Me was added to the score.


"

Uhhh...so...Home doesn't count as a vocal moment outside of Belle? That's a biiigggg solo song to be missing there...But I do agree about Jerry and Angela being the most memorable performances. Do I think Change in Me was dropped BECAUSE of Emma lack of vocal prowess? Not exactly. IF it was a factor, it certainly wasn't a big one because I'll just repeat, Menken has said on many an occasion he pretty much never planned on using the stage songs for the same reason you mentioned. They wouldn't work in the film. That's aside from anything to do with Emma.

#1472

Official

I just saw the film and thought it was lovely overall. Mainly because the director embraced the artform and understood the importance of this language. A non-literal language, sung thoughts, so he went all the way at times with wonderful cinematography, editing and pre-recorded tracks, which is essential for a musical film.

"Spoiler alert"

There were several scenes that had me in awe of sheer beauty and emotion. I loved the opening sequence with the wonderful singing of Audra and the ensemble. That really set the tone and mood. The impressive appearance of the enchantress (reminded me of Esmeralda coming out of the mirror during Hellfire in THOND), I loved the camera work and sets. Indoors and outdoors, just beautiful and theatrical. Original and playful camera work and editing in "Belle". I loved the new songs. Days in the sun was wonderfully melancholy and emotional. I loved the Beast's Evermore. I loved all parts that the wardrobe sang. These moments were spot on. Loved Lumiere, loved Mrs Potts, I loved Gaston and le Fou. It's really delightful and emotional when characters sing so well on screen. It takes the film/scenes to a higher level. Especially with pre-recorded tracks, which creates a "better than life reality" with heightened emotions. It is not about being literal, speaking the words in musical on film. The power lies in the opposite. Also, the singing of all the characters mentioned felt natural. Except for Emma Watson, the singing of the others was much more legit than anyone in, for example, the Les miserables film, yet it felt much more natural. That's why I think this film is 100 times better than the les Miserables film. Which failed at all of these things and had nothing in it that felt natural. Which should be an eye opener for producers and directors. What works better in musical on film, a non-literal approach, going all the way, or a literal approach, creating a style clash and constant switching. Definitely the first.

Now, there were also a few things that i did not like, which I think should have been better. Emma Watson's singing really felt out of place. Especially compared to the rest of the cast. When she sang the bridge in "Something there" I really thought: what a shame. Especially because it's not even necessary to see her mouthing the lyrics there. It's a sung thought. The whole film embraces this language, so why not just have a good singer as a voice over there? Or dubbing her singing in general. This was really too lifeless and lame, which did not fit the rest of the film at all.

I also felt that the parts they sung "live" on set were especially bad and autotuned. The songs recorded in a studio sounded much more glorious and truthful. "Belle" sounds weird and "Evermore" only sounds good after the first verse, which is weird.

When Belle visits the West Wing and sees the rose there was this really generic music, the moment fell completely flat, I can't believe they did not include the lush score from the animated film there. Why was that?

I did not like the librarian giving Belle the book in "Belle". That is supposed to be an older man, the only villager who understand her love for books, now it was some young, sassy gay guy who looked like he was taking the piss, but then why did he give her a book? I did not understand this scene at all. It was not genuine. I did not understand her reaction when she said "thank you' either. It was weird and forced.

What I did love was the "grandmother remark" Mrs Potts made near the end, which she took as an insult (referring to the complaints that mrs Potts has always looked more like Chip's grandma) and I loved the fact that in "Something there" when Belle threw a snowball at the beast, he actually threw one back in her face. This always bothered me in the original, because even in films today like `La La land, the male character is portrayed as a beast/A-hole in the beginning, but then later the male character always has to be goofy and charming and submissive. While in real life, of course he would throw a snowball back! And it only gives the female character more charm if she can laugh about it.

So, overall I loved it, they got many things right, but it could have been better.

Ps. A special shout-out to the fishing lady singing in the intro of The Mob song. She really went for it.







Updated On: 3/30/17 at 09:49 AM

#1473

Official

BEAUTY AND THE BEAST -- dear God.

Believe it or not, I want to love every movie I see. Really, truly. I don't ask for much, I don't think -- I'll forgive a whole lot as long as I don't feel that my intelligence is being insulted 24 frames a second for two hours. Bill Condon's CGI with humans version of Disney's BEAUTY AND THE BEAST can't manage that basic requirement. I'm in something of a state of shock here -- how could they have ****ed this up this badly?

So the good stuff. Luke Evans, as the merry macho chauvinist ****head Gaston, is actually pretty good. He's charming and funny and mean as ****, and he's so much fun that I was getting disappointed when Gaston's true villainous colors start to emerge. Emma Watson as Belle plays her role well enough, despite a strange stiffness in her upper body that made me wonder if she'd suffered some serious back injury right before production. Her singing is perfectly adequate for contemporary live action big budget movie musical -- she doesn't disgrace herself, which is more than can be said for others in other films. She's the least of the movie's problems.

OK, the bad stuff. Where to begin. I feel like it would take a vast tome of Tolstoyan dimensions to number every gross offense against basic movie-going decency committed by this piece of dreck. Here are some of the more prominent horrors.

1. The criminal waste of an overall pretty good cast. Director Bill Condon had the good sense to hire some great people in front of his camera and to pose for his motion-capture technology. Stalwarts like Ewan McGregor as Lumiere, Ian McKellen as Cogsworth the talking clock, Kevin Kline as Belle's father. Alas, they're all pretty dreadful. McGregor's Lumiere speaks with a nearly impenetrable French accent that renders his one big song, the heavily CGI'd Be Our Guest, simply unintelligible (check out the vocal by Jerry Orbach in the original for a performance that actually seems to acknowledge that those sounds are supposed to be words that actually, you know, have meanings). McKellen and Kline do the easiest hackwork of their careers -- Kline in particular seems more than a little embarrassed by the whole enterprise. And Condon went to the trouble of casting Audra McDonald, one of the great artists currently occupying space above ground, and reduces her to a Joanne Whorley impression.

2. The Beast. I just can't imagine what on earth possessed them to put Dan Stevens in the movie in the first place, unless it was the notion that they'd get some crossover PBS fans just dying to get even a heavily CGI-ed glimpse of their long-lamented Downton Abbey dreamboat. He's a pretty low-key actor, to put it politely, but his low-key performance is buried under the frankly bargain-basement CGI used to turn him into the Beast. He smiles and frowns and glowers and grimaces on cue, but there's just no real life there, no magic to animate the ones and zeroes into something interesting or memorable. Think of Andy Serkis and Peter Jackson's accomplishment with Gollum in the Middle Earth movies, and you'll get an idea of what isn't happening here. It's a colossal failure, weirdly apparent than during the resolutely un-miraculous transformation from Beast to Prince. Whatever else can be said of the Beast, he's broad-shouldered narrow-waisted and conspicuously well-muscled, and there's nothing more ridiculous than the way he dwindles into that chinless little twerp embodied by Dan Stevens wearing what looks like one of Brad Pitt's leftover wigs from that vampire movie. Garbo is supposed to have exclaimed, at the end of the Cocteau film of the story when the Beast turns into a rather effete Jean Gabin, "Give me back my Beast!" Garbo today would be saying, "Give me back my Beast's motion-capture body double!" Which brings us to:

3. The CGI. Cheap. Cheesy. To be fair, the animated furniture is pretty well done -- there's a walking piano and a pugilistic hatstand that I kinda dug on. But too much of it calls too much attention to itself as being CGI, in that "every shot has to be a showstopper" kind of way, where a character hits a high note at the end of a song and is of course standing at a window so the camera can pull out through the window and go all the way back so we can see the whole landscape to show off how much money they spent on the CGI. There's just no real flavor to it -- look folks, here's a big castle, here's a sunset, here's a forest with snow, here's a ballroom. For all the display on display, it's just ones and zeroes.

4. Holes in the story --

So the movie begins with the pre-Beast Prince refusing charity to a homeless person who turns out to be a Very Powerful Magical Person, and who then curses the Beast for having no love in his heart for not giving her shelter, and all that. Well, okay, putting aside for now the fact that it turns out that the VPMP actually lives in the woods under a fallen tree anyway, it has to be pointed out that this same VPMP, who starts the story going by Punishing Those With No Love In Their Hearts, is shown standing not five feet away from the film's real villain, Gaston, as he demonstrates Trumpian levels of brutality and hate-mongering -- and she does exactly nothing. Nada. Zip zero zilch. WTF? And remember, this character doesn't appear in the original animated film outside the opening plot exposition -- her reappearance later was added for this version, which means that Condon & Co. have actually added a major plot hole to a story that didn't have one.

And there's more -- the cynicism of the whole enterprise, in taking a movie and remaking it purely for the cash, and making such a hash of the whole thing. And the cynicism extends to Disney's trumpeting of the its First Gay Character, clearly a PR stunt to provoke religious boycotts of the film over it's Gay Character, which lets us all hate on bigots (fine by me, of course) but also deflects criticism from the frankly offensive Gay Villain sidekick stereotype, where there's a pathetic queer in love with an out of his league straight hunk.


"If they can get you asking the wrong questions, they don't have to worry about the answers." Thomas Pynchon, GRAVITY'S RAINBOW "Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away." Philip K. Dick My blog: http://www.roscoewrites.blogspot.com/
#1474

Official

"but also deflects criticism from the frankly offensive Gay Villain sidekick stereotype, where there's a pathetic queer in love with an out of his league straight hunk."

Unrequited love is an offensive stereotype? I haven't seen the movie, but from all reports the gay subtext is barely even noticeable. What made it offensive or stereotypical?

#1475

Official

Roscoe said: "Emma Watson as Belle plays her role well enough, despite a strange stiffness in her upper body that made me wonder if she'd suffered some serious back injury right before production. Her singing is perfectly adequate for contemporary live action big budget movie musical -- she doesn't disgrace herself, which is more than can be said for others in other films. She's the least of the movie's problems."

Compared to the les Mis film, where the literal approach of the live-bleating and constant switching of speaking one word and use a 5 minute vibrato bleat on the next drove me mad and makes the film completely unwatchable, and took away every for of emotion or persuasiveness and completely killed the language of sung thoughts and this artform. Emma Watson is indeed not as off-putting, but what she does is the extreme opposite. The other characters in the film create emotional magic and lift the scenes with their pre-recorded tracks. If only Belle had that same level or higher, this film would really have been something special.

I think it's the main problem of the film. Because I would like to watch it again, as long as I can fast-forward her moments.



Edit: Another thing that bothered me slightly was the fact that many songs (Be our guest, Gaston, Beauty and the Beast) had very strange and unncecessary and a-musical count changes all the time, and strange pauses between lines. Like: Be our guest, be our (2 bars rest) guest. Which made it difficult to follow the flow of a song. It was especially bad in the title song. It gives me arrhythmia. It was really far fetched at times.

Updated On: 3/30/17 at 02:45 PM

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $67