I gotta say that I honestly get a good feeling every time I read a review like yours, Alix. That there are people who adored the performance and can see the difference between JCM's Hedwig and all others. Well, after all, John did create the character and based it on actual people from his life.
I"m not really surprised that ticket sales aren't through the roof. Unfortunately, JCM isn't a name well known outside the NY theater community. It's frustrating that it takes a big show biz name to fill the seats regardless of the performance.
<-----I'M TOTES ROLLING MY EYES