From the opening post:
"In short, this is easily the best revival of a musical that Broadway has seen since Doyle's Sweeney Todd."
Well, in my opinion at least, that's setting a fairly low bar...
I found this current production of Ragtime to be good, not great, with an amazingly uneven cast. The handful who really shown were quite amazing, the vast majority were adequate, and a few were just not ready for Broadway.
With a few notable exceptions (Mother, Father, Edgar, Booker, and moments for Coalhouse and Tateh) this cast would have been the outstanding university cast of the season. I can't tell you how many moments I heard the chorus woefully out of tune, especially in the end of Act I funeral scene. (the wailing solo that I heard was actually of of tune in several keys at the same time, an exceptional feat.. and the American Idol benumbed audience I was with ate it up.. sigh...)
I must say that both Sarah and Ms. Nesbit were both in way over their abilities to sing the roles. They were both attractive enough for the roles, and Sarah decently acted, but their singing left much to be desired.
I liked the set quite a lot, very useful and well used, though nothing compared to either the original B'way set or the First National Tour set. Santos' costumes were merely lost cost versions of the originals, including the same color pallets and basic shapes, all stunningly bland.
I really missed the projections and the Model T. They gave just a sparkling finish to the earlier productions.
The orchestrations were - well, bland. What happened to the distinct klezmer and ragtime influences in the various scenes? It all sounded the same, as if there was no musical heightening for the clash of cultures. And the cut scenes added a fair amount of depth to both the characters and relationships -
All in all this was, at best, a moderately good production, worth seeing if you haven't seen the original, or are in a forgivign mood.
"It's never too late to have a happy childhood. "
- Tom Robbins