Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars

[muscle23ftl]

Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars#1

Posted: 6/14/23 at 11:28am

I realized that I tend not to agree with the winners, Strange Loop was my favorite Tony Winner...

 

Kimberly Akimbo 1

Strange Loop 5

Moulin Rouge 2

Hadestown 1

Band's Visit 1

Evan Hanson (haven't seen it)

Hamilton 1

Fun Home 1

Gentleman's Guide 2

Kinky Boots 5

Once 1

Book of Mormon 1

Memphis 3

Billy Elliot 2

In the Heights 1

Spring Awakening 4

Jersey Boys 2

Spamalot 1

Avenue Q 1

Hairspray 3

Thoroughly Modern Millie 4

 

"People have their opinions and that doesn't mean that their opinions are wrong or right. I just take it with a grain of salt because opinions are like as*holes, everyone has one". -Felicia Finley-

[noahseestheatre]

Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars#2

Posted: 6/14/23 at 11:31am

Fun Home as a 1 is a crime against humanity.

[JSquared2]

Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars#3

Posted: 6/14/23 at 11:35am

The fact that you rate most the these shows as a 1 and Memphis as a 3 tells us all we need to know about your opinions.

 

[dramamama611]

Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars#4

Posted: 6/14/23 at 12:37pm

I'll play your game. 

Kimberly Akimbo 5

Strange Loop 3

Moulin Rouge 3

Hadestown 5

Band's Visit 5

Evan Hanson 3

Hamilton 5

Fun Home 5

Gentleman's Guide 5

Kinky Boots 3

Once 5

Book of Mormon 4 (not sure I'd feel the same way now)

Memphis 1

Billy Elliot 3

In the Heights 3

Spring Awakening 5

Jersey Boys (never saw)

Spamalot 3

Avenue Q 5

Hairspray 3

Thoroughly Modern Millie 4
 

If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it? These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.

[bwayphreak234]

Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars#5

Posted: 6/14/23 at 12:41pm

Kimberly Akimbo 5

Strange Loop 4

Moulin Rouge 3

Hadestown 4

Band's Visit 2

Evan Hansen 2

Hamilton 5

Fun Home 3

Gentleman's Guide 3

Kinky Boots 3

Once 2

Book of Mormon 5

Memphis 2

Billy Elliot 5

In the Heights 3

Spring Awakening 4

Jersey Boys 4

Spamalot (never saw it)

Avenue Q 4

Hairspray 4

Thoroughly Modern Millie 4

"There’s nothing quite like the power and the passion of Broadway music. "

[flord10]

Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars#6

Posted: 6/14/23 at 12:44pm

muscle23ftl said: "I realized that I tend not to agree with the winners, Strange Loop was my favorite Tony Winner...



Kimberly Akimbo 1

Strange Loop 5

Moulin Rouge 2

Hadestown 1

Band's Visit 1

Evan Hanson (haven't seen it)

Hamilton 1

Fun Home 1

Gentleman's Guide 2

Kinky Boots 5

Once 1

Book of Mormon 1

Memphis 3

Billy Elliot 2

In the Heights 1

Spring Awakening 4

Jersey Boys 2

Spamalot 1

Avenue Q 1

Hairspray 3

Thoroughly Modern Millie 4

"

This has to be bait

[kurtal]

Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars#7

Posted: 6/14/23 at 1:14pm

Going back to RENT, the first Best Musical winner I saw.  Rating based solely on my love/experience of the show.

Kimberly Akimbo - 4/5

A Strange Loop - 4/5

Moulin Rouge! - 2/5

Hadestown - 3/5

The Band's Visit - 3/5

Dear Evan Hansen - 3/5

Hamilton - 5/5

Fun Home - 5/5

A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder - 1/5

Kinky Boots - 2/5

Once - 3/5

The Book of Mormon - 4/5

Memphis - 1/5

Billy Elliot - 3/5

In the Heights - 3/5

Spring Awakening - 4/5

Jersey Boys - did not see

Spamalot - did not see

Avenue Q - 3/5

Hairspray - 2/5

Thoroughly Modern Millie - 2/5

The Producers - 4/5

Contact - did not see

Fosse - did not see

The Lion King - 4/5

Titanic - 3/5

Rent - 4/5

[njguy2]

Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars#8

Posted: 6/14/23 at 1:20pm

Kimberly Akimbo - 4/5

A Strange Loop - 4/5

Moulin Rouge! - 4/5

Hadestown - 5/5

The Band's Visit - 3/5

Dear Evan Hansen - 4/5

Hamilton - 5/5

Fun Home - 5/5

A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder - 2/5

Kinky Boots - 3/5

Once - 3/5

The Book of Mormon - 4/5

Memphis - 2/5

Billy Elliot - 2/5

In the Heights - 3/5

Spring Awakening - 5/5

Jersey Boys - 3/5

Spamalot - 4/5

Avenue Q - 4/5

Hairspray - 3/5

Thoroughly Modern Millie - 3/5

The Producers - 4/5

Contact - 3/5

Fosse - did not see

The Lion King - 5/5

Titanic - did not see

Rent - 5/5

[heybaby]

Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars#9

Posted: 6/14/23 at 1:25pm

Kimberly Akimbo - 4

A Strange Loop - 3

Moulin Rouge! - 1

Hadestown - 3

The Band's Visit - 3

Dear Evan Hansen - 0

Hamilton - 3

Fun Home - 5

A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder - didn't see

Kinky Boots - 5

Once - 2

The Book of Mormon - 5

Memphis - 0

Billy Elliot - 5

In the Heights - 4

Spring Awakening - 5

Jersey Boys - didn't see

Spamalot - 5

Avenue Q - 4

Hairspray - 5

Thoroughly Modern Millie - 4

The Producers - 4

Contact - didn't see

Fosse - didn't see

The Lion King - 4

Titanic - didn't see

Rent - 5

Updated On: 6/14/23 at 01:25 PM

[Jarethan]

Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars#10

Posted: 6/14/23 at 1:33pm

Kimberly Akimbo - 3/5

A Strange Loop - Didn’t see

Moulin Rouge! - 5/5

Hadestown - 2/5

The Band's Visit - 3/5

Dear Evan Hansen - 5/5

Hamilton - 5/5

Fun Home - 2/5

A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder - 5/5

Kinky Boots - 4/5

Once - 2/5

The Book of Mormon - 3/5

Memphis - 3/5

Billy Elliot - 3/5

In the Heights - 3/5

Spring Awakening - 4/5

Jersey Boys - 2/5

Spamalot - 3/5

Avenue Q - 1/5

Hairspray - 4/5

Thoroughly Modern Millie - 3/5

The Producers - 5/5

Contact - 2/5

Fosse - 0/5 (Hated/Hated/Hated…so pretentious)

The Lion King - 3/5 

Titanic - 3/5

Rent - 3/5

 

[broadway86]

Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars#11

Posted: 6/14/23 at 4:45pm

Kimberly Akimbo 3/5

Strange Loop 5/5

Moulin Rouge 1.5/5

Hadestown 5/5

Band's Visit 4.5/5

Evan Hanson (haven't seen it) 2/5

Hamilton 5/5

Fun Home 4/5

Gentleman's Guide 3.5/5

Kinky Boots 4/5

Once 4/5

Book of Mormon 2.5/5

Memphis 2.5/5

Billy Elliot 3.5/5

In the Heights 4/5

Spring Awakening 4

Jersey Boys 3.5/5

Spamalot 4/5

Avenue Q 5/5

Hairspray 4.5/5

Thoroughly Modern Millie 3.5/5

Updated On: 6/14/23 at 04:45 PM

[Theatrefanboy1]

Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars#12

Posted: 6/14/23 at 5:24pm

Kimberly Akimbo 4

Strange Loop 1/0

Moulin Rouge 3/4

Hadestown 4/5

Band's Visit 1

Evan Hanson (haven't seen it) 4

Hamilton 1

Fun Home 1

Gentleman's Guide 1

Kinky Boots 3

Once 1

Book of Mormon 3

Memphis 1

Billy Elliot 4/5

In the Heights 1

Spring Awakening 4

Jersey Boys 2

Spamalot 2

Avenue Q 2

Hairspray 3

Thoroughly Modern Millie 2

[Mr. Wormwood]

Rate the Tony Award Winners for Best Musical from 1 to 5 Stars#13

Posted: 6/14/23 at 5:32pm

Kimberly Akimbo - seeing it this summer
A Strange Loop - never saw
Moulin Rouge - 2
Hadestown - 4.5
The Band's Visit - 1
Dear Evan Hansen - 4
Hamilton - 5
Fun Home - 3.5
A Gentlemen's Guide - 1
Kinky Boots - never saw
Once - never saw
The Book of Mormon - 4
Memphis - 3
Billy Elliott - never saw
In the Heights - never saw
Spring Awakening - 1
Jersey Boys - 3
Spamalot - 1
Avenue Q - 5
Hairspray - 5
Thoroughly Modern Millie - 3.5
The Producers - 4

Older ones I've seen:
The Lion King - 3
Rent - 1
Crazy For You - 4
Phantom of the Opera - 3