Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys- Page 3
Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
CurtainPullDowner
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/4/04
#51Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/22/15 at 11:04pm
Audra McDonald- Mister Snow from Carousel
#52Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/23/15 at 8:31am"My New Philosophy" for Kristen Chenowith in YOU'RE A GOOD MAN CHARLIE BROWN
Gothampc
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/20/03
#53Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/23/15 at 10:24am
Songs do not give performers tonys performances do. One song especially does not give you a TONY
I have to partially disagree with this. I think there are certain songs that certain performers have connected with and taken so far above the expectation that it has tipped in their favor. You can feel the electricity when a performer completely nails a song. I've only seen it a very few times, but the performer had the entire audience spellbound.
In addition, what do you do with the one song winners? For example, Betty Buckley won for Grizabella in Cats. You can't deny that the song Memory won her the award because Grizabella doesn't sing anything else and it's not like the character has a huge story arc. She drags herself onstage, sings Memory, drags herself offstage, reappears and climbs a ladder.
Patti LuPone won an Olivier for playing Fantine in Les Miserables (yeah I know we're talking Tonys). Fantine has one song and then dies.
AEA AGMA SM
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/13/09
#54Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/23/15 at 10:40am
I think there is a difference between "the song won them their Tony" and "their performance of that one song won them their Tony." To me the first implies that the song is so good that anybody would have won the award for singing it onstage. In a way that discounts the actors' performances and everything they brought to that role. It implies the song is completely actor-proof, and judging by some of the horrible renditions of all of these songs you can find all over Youtube it's easy to see that is rarely, if ever, the case.
Most of the mentions here were great combinations of the right actor with the right material at the right time. Any slight change in that combination could have completely changed the way we view both these songs and these actors.
#55Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/23/15 at 10:42am
"Songs do not give performers tonys performances do. One song especially does not give you a TONY
I have to partially disagree with this. I think there are certain songs that certain performers have connected with and taken so far above the expectation that it has tipped in their favor. You can feel the electricity when a performer completely nails a song. I've only seen it a very few times, but the performer had the entire audience spellbound."
I realize this a tricky issue. What I meant in conception of this post was songs that are so grand and amazing that that was a main component of their win.
You make the point I was trying to make with your Patti-Olivier point.
This thread has been very goos so far and I think the community has come up with a lot of good stuff.
Gothampc
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/20/03
#56Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/23/15 at 10:45am
In order to test this theory, I think Broadway needs to mount another production of "Promises, Promises" and see if the actress playing Marge wins a Tony. Two for two so far with the role of Marge.
Gothampc
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/20/03
#57Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/23/15 at 10:52am
You make the point I was trying to make with your Patti-Olivier point.
Actually, there has to be a big "exception" with that. After I checked it, I realized that Patti was awarded the Olivier for two performances "Les Miserables" and "Cradle Will Rock." I don't know why they tacked on "Cradle Will Rock" so one of the Brits will have to explain how the Oliviers work.
#58Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/23/15 at 10:53am
I profoundly disagree with most of the suggestions in this thread. Finnernan was delightful in the song 'A Fact Can Be a Beautiful Thing,' but nearly every word uttered from her mouth brought the house down. The owl impression is something I remember more than the number. The role may have been small, but from her entrance to her exit, she walked away with the show.
After 'Call From the Vatican,' I knew that Krakowski had it in the bag...but still, the moment I most remember from her performance was her sitting quietly in a chair trying to put back together the divorce papers Guido had just torn in half. It was devastating.
Most of these performances were so complete from beginning to end. The way McDonald gave herself over to Stokes at the end of NEW MUSIC was as affecting as her 'Daddy's Son.' Even their silent dance together in Act 2 where they never touched reached a theatrical height that the entirety of Act 2 of RAGTIME couldn't replicate.
The only two I really agree with are Buckley in CATS since it really is the only song she sings, and Andrea Martin in PIPPIN because, well, same.
broadwaysfguy
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/27/14
#59Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/24/15 at 9:51am
I love this thread and any thread where i can discover great broadway songs and performances
thanks poster!
most of these actors won for much more than just the song attached, but these songs may have sealed the deal....
Billy Porter Kinky Boots-Hold me in your heart
Jessie Mueller-Beautiful-will you still love me tomorrow
Kelli O'Hara- the king and I-Getting to Know You
Heather Headley-aida-The Gods love Nubia
Matthew Broderick-How to Succeed-I believe In You
Nikki St James-Book of mormon-sal ta lay ka see tee
Balthazar Chasen
Chorus Member Joined: 5/18/15
#60Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/24/15 at 12:57pm
Dee Dee Bridgewater singing If You Believe in The Wiz!
#61Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/24/15 at 3:14pm
She drags herself onstage, sings Memory, drags herself offstage, reappears and climbs a ladder.
She doesn't climb a ladder. She rides on a flying tire. DUH!
#62Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/24/15 at 5:26pm
"most of these actors won for much more than just the song attached, but these songs may have sealed the deal....
Heather Headley-aida-The Gods love Nubia"
I agree that her whole performance overall won her the Tony Award, but I'd single out "Easy As Life" as her showcase song rather than "The Gods Love Nubia".
#63Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/24/15 at 6:24pm
Kelli O'Hara- the king and I-Getting to Know You
I think it was the gorgeous acting that won Kelli the Tony, and even if it was for a song it would be for Hello Young Lovers - not Getting to Know You (In y opinion, the worst song in the score).
Rumpelstiltskin
Broadway Star Joined: 4/22/07
#64Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/24/15 at 6:53pm
" The only two I really agree with are Buckley in CATS since it really is the only song she sings, and Andrea Martin in PIPPIN because, well, same. "
In the case of Andrea Martin, would you agree that it wasn't necessarily the song that won her the award, but instead it was equal parts the song, the unexpected and unique staging of the song, and her ability to handle what was asked of her? I loved the scene, but I'd argue that several people deserved the recognition she received.
Has anyone ever won for a great performance of a poorly-staged rendition of a truly bad song?
#65Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/24/15 at 7:09pm
"In the case of Andrea Martin, would you agree that it wasn't necessarily the song that won her the award, but instead it was equal parts the song, the unexpected and unique staging of the song, and her ability to handle what was asked of her? I loved the scene, but I'd argue that several people deserved the recognition she received."
I think you're right: it was definitely a combination of Schwartz's song, her ability, and Paulus' staging.
broadwaysfguy
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/27/14
#66Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/24/15 at 7:29pm
hi piano mann
great minds think alike
I was 50-50 on suggesting either easy as life or gods love nubia, both complete showstoppers that were EXTRAORDINARY
would love an aida broadway revival SOON
Actriz2
Stand-by Joined: 3/5/15
#67Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/24/15 at 7:53pm
"Kelli O'Hara- the king and I-Getting to Know You
I think it was the gorgeous acting that won Kelli the Tony, and even if it was for a song it would be for Hello Young Lovers - not Getting to Know You (In y opinion, the worst song in the score).
"
I would argue that it was a scene - not a song - that won Kelli the Tony. When she was defending Tuptim from the King during the whipping scene (particularly with her delivery of the "you are a barbarian" line) I thought she had the Tony in the bag.
#68Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/25/15 at 2:18pm
I think Kelli getting the Tony had a little more to do then just her King and I performance. It was Kristin's powerhouse performance vs. 6 amazing performances for Kelli O'Hara.
Balthazar Chasen
Chorus Member Joined: 5/18/15
#69Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/26/15 at 3:28pm
SUPPERTIME from YOU'RE A GOOD MAN CHARLIE, BROWN for Roger Bart as Snoopy. Although it was probably the holistic totality of his performance that won him the Tony, his knockout delivery of SUPPERTIME certainly didn't hurt.
#70Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/26/15 at 11:20pm
Oh, here's one: Chenowith - Charlie Brown!
Updated On: 6/26/15 at 11:20 PM
#71Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/26/15 at 11:43pm
It's Not Where you Start it's where you finish... Tommy Tune and Seesaw.
#72Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/28/15 at 7:52pm
How about "Music of the Night" for Michael Crawford?
#73Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/29/15 at 6:39am
The Impossible Dream/ Richard Kiley.
#74Songs That Won Their Performers Tonys
Posted: 6/29/15 at 6:52am
As great as Christian Borle is in Rotten, I'm sure "Will Power" lent a helping hand to his Tony. Too bad we couldn't see any of his performance on the Tony's. I agree with the number they showed though. That was a great way to start the show.
Videos