Jarethan said: "LarryD2 said: "Roscoe -- I remember the moment you describe vividly. And to me it captures one of the essential elements of Channing's performance: the effortless subtlety she brought to the role, something I've yet to see anyone who's played it since achieve. There were no big, grand gestures or tricks in her characterization. It felt entirely real, and she really seemed of the world Guare was creating.
In contrast, Allison Janney -- who I thought looked like a million bucks, with great costumes and wigs -- totally seemed crass and overstated from the very beginning of her performance."
To me, Allison Janney is a highly acclaimed actress who all too often just playsherself, tall, loud, articulate, slightly larger than life(rare exception: American Beauty, in which she was outstanding). I don't think she is capable of subtlety, which the role required IMO."
I thought it was only me. I do like her, she can be outrageously funny (see Drop Dead Gorgeous for an example), but I couldn't imagine her as Ouisa and it closed before I could get past that.