Well...what is arguably the best musical production of the season is now running at 2ST. If you can manage to snag a ticket to this, do it. This is a really special production of a really special show.
I love THE LAST FIVE YEARS, while I do recognize it's flaws. Most of which are inherent in the entire premise of the way the story is told. But it's an ambitious, very enjoyable show, with a fantastic score. And the truth is, the show rises or falls based on its Cathy and Jamie. And I am happy to say that this production has two fantastic performers at its center. I have to completely disagree with the "no chemistry" comments, which simply may have subsided as the preview period has worn on. But I completely bought Wolfe and Kantor, both individually and together. They are, however, certainly a
different Cathy and Jamie than Butz and Scott were and I appreciated that.
I've never been a major Betsy Wolfe lover and I was sorta worried about how she would fare in this production, but she is sensational. What. A. Voice. She finds new and refreshing nuances to Cathy that are really strong character choices and she sings this score so beautifully that it could make you melt. There was a moment tonight where she almost fell off of her chair during "Climbing Uphill." She yelped mid song, caught herself, didn't miss a beat, and in the next break, she mumbled (in character) "...embarrassing." She had the audience eating out of the palm of her hand, mishaps and all. Adam Kantor is wonderful as well and he has fantastic vocal control, but I wish he would cut the riffing down to a minimum. Don't get me wrong, he hits all of the right notes and sounds nice doing so, but there was a little too much riffing for my taste tonight. And then when he would get to the longer, sustained notes, he seemed almost out of steam. And vocally, he seemed to be mimicking Butz here and there. His acting, however, couldn't be better. I completely bought his Jamie's whole arc; he's charming and funny, but he also impresses when his storyline goes to a more melancholy place.
The show is directed with such a careful, beautiful, steady hand by Jason Robert Brown. There are minimal sets, which work very effectively and slide in and out for each sequence. The orchestra is set on varying levels at the back wall of the stage and they couldn't have sounded more lovely.
My issues with this production are largely nit-picky, because overall it's simply wonderful. The 90 minute running time passes so quickly, I was hoping JRB wrote a second act for this revival. I didn't want to go home! It's a very moving, very beautiful, and very charming production of a gem of a musical. I'm glad to hear it's selling so well and I wish this production nothing but success and great reviews.
Updated On: 3/19/13 at 10:13 PM