HamilHansen said: "Don't see Borle as Todd or Jones as Lovett, but I'd love to be proven wrong.
That said, Slater, Kritzer, Page, and Steele are spot on! I'd LOVE to have them in those roles (and sell my soul to see them as well)
"
I realize that Borle and Bay Jones may not be actors who scream Todd and Lovett, but after I went over several potential leads, the two of them were the best I could think of. I believe they are both extremely talented and incredibly versatile performers, and I’d be willing to watch them act in just about anything. Christian Borle has actually said in an interview that Sweeney Todd is a dream role, which leads me to believe he’d be willing to fully commit himself to that monster of a part. Also, while he’s primarily known as a comedic actor, I believe most people will agree that his work in Falsettos showed that he can excel in a juicy, dramatic part. While Marvin is a total saint compared to Sweeney, some of his actions in the first half of the show are legitimately monstrous, and Borle’s at times unhinged performance was chilling, especially in the famous “Marvin Goes Crazy/Hits Trina” scene. Rachel Bay Jones’ performances in Pippin and Dear Evan Hansen proved that she can be completely hilarious and heartbreakingly honest, which are both key elements to being Nellie Lovett. I also believe that her wonderfully warm presence could make her one of the more unique Lovetts. It would cause some of her sweeter moments to come across as genuinely endearing, while also making her diabolical actions even more unnerving. Hell, seeing such a lovable actress become such a loathsome character could actually make her Lovett almost as terrifying as Sweeney.
Also, I’m very proud of of the cast members you mentioned. To me, Slater exudes such a likable, childlike energy. I believe he’d make for a lively and tragic Toby. I honestly couldn’t think of a single other performer that I’d want to see do the role. Not only could he act the part beautifully, he also has the perfect voice and face for it. Not too young, but not too old. I’ve personally always preferred for Toby to be played by a young adult rather than a child actor. The role’s not exactly easy to sing, and it just sounds much better with a more developed voice. Not to mention, the audience should actually find the character to be scary by the end of the show, which is definitely harder for a minor to pull off. Kritzer, meanwhile is one of those performers who is truly excellent in whatever she does. I believe she’d be totally game to tackle the Beggar Woman. Her voice against that beautiful and frantic music would be delightful, and I think she’d be able to perfectly pull off her craziness while also never forgetting to give hints about the woman underneath the insanity. And I don’t think anyone can deny that her Pirelli would be sidesplitting. As for Page, if you put a low note or a villain in front of him, he’s going to knock it out of the park. Another reason why Page would be ideal is because he never approaches a villain as a villain. He always tries to find a legitimate reason for their actions to base his performance around, which is perfect for Turpin, since outside of his big solo, the Judge never seems to have any idea that he’s a disgustingly awful human being. I believe it’s easy for an actor to make Judge Turpin into a one dimensional character, but if Patrick Page got his hands on the part, he’d bring out just the right amount of horror and depth. And finally, anyone who saw Great Comet knows that Lucas Steele can hit truly breathtaking high notes, and be deliciously hammy, which are the two ultimate necessities to correctly portraying the Beadle.
Updated On: 7/19/19 at 12:02 AM