"Wow, I thought it was really popular. Guess I was wrong. Maybe that's why it was easy for my sister to get the discount tickets then."
So because two people didn't like it, you assume it wasn't popular? It was very popular, it was a hit, it ran for years, it recouped it's investment... When a show dies down and puts up a closing notice, everyone with tickets after it's final performance is contacted. This is protocol.
"It's a musical that shows that there are people out there who care about the creative process of musical theatre and not just throwing up a well known movie on stage or using the songs of a pop band to formulate a Broadway show."
I'm ALL for original musicals, but this statement really rubs me the wrong way. There are plenty of creative teams and writers and producers who care very much about musical theatre and creating a worthy product... whose projects are based on a movie or existing music. It's ridiculous to assume that just because a product has source material, the creators are sell- outs who could care less about what they're "throwing up" on stage. Regardless of level of success, there are plenty of movie- based musicals and jukebox musicals that were created with all the heart, effort, and genuine belief afforded any project.
"Okay Winston, I challenge you to come up with a list of 20 musicals (not counting anything that opened this season) not based on source material."
Well there ARE plenty of those. YankeeFan, I bet you could name 20 too. But just for kicks, ones I can think of: A My Name Is Alice, The Act, [title of show], Allegro, Baby, Starting Here Starting Now, Closer Than Ever, Last 5 Years, Songs for a New World, John and Jen, Brownstone, Follies, Brooklyn, In Trousers, March of the Falsettos, Falsettoland, Elegies: A Song Cycle, A New Brain, Elegies for Punks Angels and Raging Queens, Thirteen, Bare, A Class Act, The Thing About Men, I Love You You're Perfect Now Change, Fade Out- Fade In, Hair...
Obviously those are off the top of my head, because I got on a William Finn tangent at one point...
The main point is that this thread makes my head hurt. But it was interesting to try to think of completely source material- less musicals... like Drowsy...
[title of show] on Broadway. it's time. believe.