VERY interesting. Some quick things I noticed/thought of:
COME FROM AWAY and ANASTASIA are the only Broadway musicals nominated for Best Musical.
Denee Benton snubbed again.
Nick Cordero could by the Tony representation for A BRONX TALE.
GROUNDHOG DAY snubbed with the exception of Andy Karl. Seems like it's not the safe bet people thought it was...
"Oh look at the time, three more intelligent plays just closed and THE ADDAMS FAMILY made another million dollars" -Jackie Hoffman, Broadway.com Audience Awards
Remember that these are the people who snubbed Kelli O'Hara a few years ago for King and I. There's even less correlation with the DDs and the Tonys than the OCCs and the Tonys. Don't put too much stock in these.
bjh2114 said: "Remember that these are the people who snubbed Kelli O'Hara a few years ago for King and I. There's even less correlation with the DDs and the Tonys than the OCCs and the Tonys. Don't put too much stock in these."
Indeed. The DD have, I think, the widest net of potential nominees- Broadway, Off-Broadway, and Off-Off Broadway, not to mention special events like productions at the Armory. You have far more competition for each individual award- and again, things will get knocked out of consideration if they are transfers of a production that was recently considered.
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."
I AM a little confused how Chavkin got in for Great Comet. I get the design elements changing to fit a different space (and thus being eligible), but ultimately the directorial vision is still the same as before... just expanded.
I know the Drama Desks are unpredictable, but I am completely astounded by the fact that Paloma Young was not nominated for Great Comet, one of the most mammoth costuming achievements in recent theater history. Not only do they span centuries of history, they are clearly designed to be appreciated from 4 feet away as well as from the back of the rear mezzanine.
Of all the awards shows you can use as predictors for the Tonys, the DDs are probably the least relevant because they are so broad. Kad makes a really good point.
PaulWom said: "I know the Drama Desks are unpredictable, but I am completely astounded by the fact that Paloma Young was not nominated for Great Comet, one of the most mammoth costuming achievements in recent theater history. Not only do they span centuries of history, they are clearly designed to be appreciated from 4 feet away as well as from the back of the rear mezzanine."
I doubt they were eligible. The costumes are the one design element that haven't really changed a ton since the off-Broadway incarnation. Paloma would have eligible then.
bjh2114 said: "I AM a little confused how Chavkin got in for Great Comet. I get the design elements changing to fit a different space (and thus being eligible), but ultimately the directorial vision is still the same as before... just expanded.
"
Based on the OCC ruling they put out when they announced nominations, it seems that the idea is that "new" aspects of Comet are eligible for the precursor awards? That's probably why we didn't see Lucas Steele and Amber Gray.
Nonetheless, I am a little disappointed in the snub of Groundhog Day's score (brilliant) and Denee Benton. However, I am reminded of the 2013 race where Patina Miller was snubbed from the DD Leading Actress Category and still went on to win the Tony, so we can't (as usual) call anything yet.
haterobics said: "Kad said: "Well, Great Comet and Dear Evan Hansen were presumably ineligible for any elements that had been nominated or eligible previously."
Same with Significant Other?"
I would assume so, yes, as the production was essentially the same as it was at the Pels.
As for the costumes: it seems Paloma Young was nominated for Great Comet back in 2013, so maybe that makes her ineligible as her expanded work for Broadway was not deemed sufficiently different (after all, the principals costuming was the same)? But Chavkin was nominated for her direction that year. So who knows?
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."
The Drama Desk nominations might be unpredictable, because they can choose from Broadway, Off-Broadway and Off-Off-Broadway, but the winners almost always are so predictable (other than for an exception like ''Hamilton'' ).
Every year, the Broadway shows win about 90% of the Drama Desk Awards because that's what more of its members have seen. Whereas Off-Broadway shows often have shorter or limited runs, and have come and gone. So if you want to predict the winners, go down each category, narrow it down to the Broadway nominees, pick the best-known name, and that's usually your winner.
That may be true, but the nominations are still weird. I would have expected (in the absence of Dear Evan Hansen and Great Comet) for Groundhog Day to get many nominations and, as a result, several wins. Now I'd guess that Come From Away will take most of these.
I honestly wonder if Benton and Groban pulled their names from consideration for the OCC and Drama Desks in a show of solidarity for Steele and Gray who are ineligible akin to how J. Robert Spencer pulled his name from consideration for next to normal, since Ripley, Tveit, and Damiano were ineligible.