I saw this in Chicago and, with a year of perspective, it's kind of funny how this didn't really work. It had elements that really could have worked in a better show, but some choices were just baffling.
1. Andie's friends. Everyone these days makes jokes about how terrible Andie's friends are in the movie. So you'd think a musical in 2022 updating the story would either axe the characters, or give them a total re-write. Imagine my shock when the characters were not only present, but their horrible personalities were doubled-down on and they were STILL presented as being in the right. Baffling choice.
2. Emily is one of the best characters in the movie, and she was changed into a total caricature here. On one hand I have to commend the creators for not just doing a copy-and-paste for everything, but boy was that a bizarre take on her character.
3. From the moment I saw they had Beth in a brown wig, I knew something was off. Miranda's look is so iconic, and the white hair is a big part of that. Any actress in the role was probably going to be underserved, as Miranda only really had one song towards the end, but boy was Beth just laid out to dry here. She was giving it her best, so it was still entertaining, but she had little to work with. Her "That's All" patter song and the Cerulean song (if it was considered a full song) were memorable for me.
Overall the production just wreaked of wasted potential. The big scenic moments (I'm thinking the Eiffel Tower transition, the red stairway to "Hell," and the dress forms descending from the ceiling during Nigel's song) were very memorable but stood out too much because the rest of the production was pretty bare. The performers were all underserved. This would basically need a complete re-do (with potentially keeping some of the standout moments listed above) for it to have a chance of working on Broadway.