BroadwayNYC2 said: "But in what universe would Donna Murphy not be a “boring” choice? She checks all the obvious boxes as well. Love her, but let’s not pretend like she ain’t incredibly on the nose either."
There's a difference between "obvious, but would like to see it" and "obvious, but boring," but of course we're talking about personal opinions. I found Vanessa Williams to be absolutely lifeless on stage in Anyone Can Whistle (where she also demonstrated a greatly deteriorated singing voice), POTUS, and Sondheim on Sondheim. Where someone like Murphy can sometimes surprise us when she's an "obvious" choice for something, I've rarely been surprised or thrilled by Williams onstage.
Maybe she'll be brilliant! Who knows.
(My belief for a while has been that they should go with a British, talk-singing Miranda. Someone like Lindsay Duncan or Juliet Stevenson. But those ladies also aren't a far walk from Meryl, which is one of the perils of this role and why some might not want to take it.)
Updated On: 2/18/24 at 12:13 PM