Posted: 4/18/23 at 10:30pm
Turns out Neil reached out for 2 hours and 15 minutes, and it touched me, somehow. I liked this better than I thought I would, given the reviews. No understudies, and Sonny Paladino conducted.
Will Swenson gives a restrained performance but knows when and how to let loose. I suppose the same could be said of tonight's audience. Respectful, and singing and clapping along AT THE RIGHT MOMENTS. They even clapped to the final chorus of "Holly Holy" at the end of the show.
Those last 15 minutes make for one of the best extended sequences I've seen in a jukebox musical in some time. It gives Mark Jacoby an outsider's chance at a Best Leading Actor in a Musical slot. Stunning book work (credit Anthony McCarten here too), and when he finally opens up with "I Am... I Said" and sings with Swenson, it felt very heartwarming.
Robyn Hurder was dynamite, and I'm so glad I finally got to see her in a show!
HOLY SH*T THAT ENSEMBLE. Jordan Dobson may have ditched 'em for Belleville, but they are as pitch-perfect as can be (which I also said on the cast album thread for this show). I also love the racial and body diversity on display. I'm sure Paladino and AnnMarie Milazzo had a field day creating the stunning vocal lines and orchestral arrangements throughout the performance. WOW.
McCarten's book is just fine, nothing to write home about until those final 15. Does anyone else think the Streisand reference in Act Two is intentional, as director Michael Mayer also helmed Funny Girl?
I liked Steven Hoggett's choreography, though it is a bit questionable from time to time. Creepy in particular during "Hands... touching hands...". The ensemble leaning in to hear Diamond sing at the Bitter End is a better gesture.
Stage door tonight wasn't a big mob. Only Hurder signed everyone's Playbills. No sight of Swenson or Jacoby. MiMi Scardulla was also nice enough to sign my Playbill.
Swenson delivered the BC/EFA appeal. Signed posters for $100, signed Playbills for $40.
I don't know how long this will last in NYC, and how many Tony noms it gets (if any) on the 2nd, but I think this should (and probably will) be a hit on tour.
Okay. Okay. Okay.
Updated On: 4/18/23 at 10:30 PM