Okay, here goes.
The Good:
- JAMES T. LANE!!!!!!! While I have no comparison point, his first performance was essentially flawless. This is a man who knows his way around a jazz-age musical (Chicago, After Midnight, Kiss Me Kate, and others) and so he got the vocal growl down as well as the rhythm. I wish he had more choreography (knowing he’s a magnificent dancer), but he’s seldom off stage, so I suppose that’s a fine trade off. Honestly, Lane set a high standard of what this role could be that I don’t have much of an interest in seeing Iglehart’s take since I can’t imagine him topping that.
- Trista Dollison, Darlesia Cearcy, and Jennie Harney-Fleming: All three were fantastic as the wives. Dollison was on again for Dionne Figgins and she was sassy, brassy, and vocally talented. Cearcy was the best choice for the wife to close the show, but Harney-Fleming might be the wife most remembered during awards season. She’s shrewd and tough - like a jazz age Cookie Lyon. (Unfortunately, while Kim Exum has a nice song, her wife character seemed to just be a passing plot device)
- The Orchestrations: Anytime you hand Branford Marsalis a jazz score, you will get magic and then some. I will say nothing else.
The Okay:
- The Choreography: Now, the choreography is fantastic, especially when DeWitt Fleming has a show stopping moment mid show. However, some parts are overchoreographed a bit and could stand some cuts.
- The Set: It kind of reminded me of Lempicka with all the stairs, platforms and catwalks. There are some computerized elements, but it’s otherwise pretty pedestrian.
- The Song Choices: I get they wanted to cover his whole oeuvre as much as they could but we did not need multiple reprises of the Tiger Rag or a scene where he sings “You’ll Be Glad When You’re Dead…” to the Memphis Police Department. Which brings me to…
The Bad:
The Book: It’s both exhaustive and exhausting. It covers a majority of his life from when he met his first wife to his death. However, A LOT of details are crammed in at the expense of fleshing out characters or framing the story in a more interesting way. Honestly, the way the wives were spectrally coming in and out of some scenes, I feel like I would’ve preferred they taken the “Jelly’s Last Jam” route and used them to tell the story, instead of using and disposing of them as quickly and Louis himself did. Also, there are multiple half-assed subplots about mob involvement and the like that could stand to be reduced.
- The Pace: The show started at 2:01 and ended at 4:50. That’s a LONG show for a musical. Obviously, there is an intermission and I have the attention span and capacity, but quite a few times, I was like “speed it up - why do I care about this”.
The Upside is that the cast at the Stage Door said they are making quite a few cuts and changes and to come back once it’s frozen. I’m going back in two weeks so we shall see.
While not the greatest offering currently out there, it’s damn entertaining, James T. Lane has a star turn, and it’s comparatively better to a lot of other things I’ve seen open this season so far.
Check out my eBay page for sales on Playbills!!
www.ebay.com/usr/missvirginiahamm