ErmengardeStopSniveling said: "macbeth said: "Has this happened before post-Broadway?"
If you scroll up and read the thread you'll see multiple examples cited.
Among the many shows that have been revised after the initial Broadway run:
MERRILY
ADDAMS FAMILY
BIG FISH
FOOTLOOSE
GOLDEN RAINBOW
I CAN GET IT FOR YOU WHOLESALE
COMPANY
FOLLIES
THE SOUND OF MUSIC
ANNIE GET YOUR GUN
SHOW BOAT
CABARET
ON A CLEAR DAY"
The difference is though, that to my understanding, none of those shows were developed in spaces like The O'Neill, which specifically caters to new works and development for a public audience.
I'm positive there were private table reads/workshops for all of those revisions but The O'Neill is a public entity solely for development for a paying audience with the intention of highlighting new work/adaptations that hasn't been staged.
Perhaps I'm being overdramatic, but I say shame on The O'Neill for this. Someone pointed out Yorkey is on the board, so that's definitely how this happened, but it angers me that the space they're occupying could've been given to a new, greener team with a property that was either a) original or b) adapted from obscure, under-appreciated material. I guess I don't really understand the purpose, other than O'Neill benefitting financially from the short-term and the long term with licensing agreements, as to why this is happening. So many talented people I know with original projects in the industry have to all but sing for their supper to get anyone to give a rat's ass about their work and these guys already had a Broadway run.