I’ve seen both and easily prefer Sutton.
I saw this before, she’s just as excellent in this role. At some points I thought of how I preferred her a decade ago, but there’s the trade off of her being even better in other spots.
The rest of the cast is also good, but all of them were weaker than their Broadway counterparts except for Robert Lindsay and Carly Mercedes Dyer (though I still did very much enjoy Haydn Oakley).
I’m not as into Dyer’s portrayal as others were, but she’s a definite improvement on Jessica Stone’s take, which was solid but bland. Robert Lindsay was a fantastic scene stealer. I love Joel Grey, but while he was charming and fun, his performance was awkward and sort of unfocused at times. I feel bad that Lindsay lost the Olivier, cause he really should’ve been in supporting where he was initially expected to win, though at least he’s already got a few.