I will try to keep an open mind with Ashford and sorry to be over dramatic while I clutch my pearls and say a prayer with my hand held to the OBC Sweeney CD but it makes me almost want to cry to think about the missed opportunities. For me she made the Sunday revival Dot far less affecting than it should have been and it’s one of my favourite shows and I thought an amazing production. Heck, we even had Carolee Carmello do great in the role off Broadway and recent Tony nominee Carmen Cusack just did the role regionally. She is following PATTI LUPONE. Is Ashford REALLY the best they could find?
I have seen some of my fav performances ever in Sondheim NYC revivals (eg Bernadette in Night Music and Follies; Lansbury and Stritch in Night Music; Lenk and LuPone in Company; Jake in SITPWG; Donna Murphy in Encores Whistle; Raul in Company filming etc). The kind of performances that help you get to sleep when life or this world ****ing sucks because it reminds you what the good parts of ‘being alive’ are. The first opportunity to see the show that got me into musicals and Sondheim on Broadway and this is the best they could do? The first Sweeney revival since Sondheim died and this is the best they could do? I have been waiting almost 15 years for Bernadette to do the role, and fine she is probably too old now but that speaks to the kind of level needed for this role. In the nytimes 2000 Frank rich Sondheim article Sondheim was asked what his fav male and female performances were in his shows and he listed Bernadette in Sunday, Lansbury in Sweeney and Ethel Merman in Gypsy. This is the level that she is taking on right now so she and the director better know what they are bringing to the table. If this Sweeney disappoints I fully expect Gypsy to be the next show on the gallows to compete a trilogy of tolerable but uninspiring Sondheim performances. Because this is the problem really, yes Ashford is actually a good singer and a good actor but it’s not good enough to be good - you need that one in a million quality that people like Bernadette, LuPone, Lansbury, Donna, Marin, Audra, Stritch bring. When you are taking on the best role in the best show by the best composer in the best musical theatre district that has been performed by the best in the past you had better be ready to bring it!!!
Give me claws and a hunch, just away from this bunch.
Updated On: 7/29/22 at 03:01 AM