Best "stunt cast"?

Having Laura Linney and Cynthia Nixon swap performances in The Little Foxes.

Reba McEntire in ANNIE GET YOUR GUN.

What's considered stunt casting? Reba can sing, so I guess I don't consider that to be stunt casting necessarily. Is it more depending on whether the person has theater experience versus just singing and performing experience?

I guess I take stunt casting as when someone joins a show already running. Someone opening up a show doesn't strike me as stunt casting. Reba coming in after Bernadette left ANNIE GET YOUR GUN was stunt casting of the best kind. It kept the show open and she was fabulous.

There have been so many threads on this exact topic over the years, and EVERY SINGLE TIME it leads to a debate about what distinguishes "stunt" casting from "star" casting.

Call_me_jorge said: "Bette Midler and Jake both stunted the gross of both shows. There’s no way they would make as much money as they did without them. Sure they are both talented, but it’s still stunt casting."

Jake has done a lot of stage work over the last 5 years. Hiring him to be in another play is not stunt casting. Bette has been doing shows and singing live on stage for years. Having her sing live on stage in a show... also not stunt casting. Revenue is not the sole determinant of what constitutes stunt casting. And I don't think "stunted the gross" means what you think it means.

dearalanaaaa said: "No doubt in my mind, Brendon Urie in Kinky Boots. I honestly don't know how nobody has mentioned that so far."

Beat me to the punch!

Billie Joe Armstrong in American Idiot

To me, Stunt Casting is always about replacements. How are we going to come up with creative ways to make the show run longer. Examples to me are:



-- Zsa Zsa Gabor in 40 Carats. In what galaxy would Zsa Zsa and Julie Harris play the same role? And the grosses go up when the Tony award winning lead left (of course, she did win in one of the worst seasons for non-musicals ever).

-- Melanie Griffith in Chicago. -- Bebe Neuwirth coming back to play Roxie and Matron Mama Morton...I remember specifically that Roxie was during the winter doldrums. Clearly stunt casting.

-- Rosie O'Donnell in Suessical.

-- Richard Burton in Equus. This may not even be stunt casting, since he was a great actor who had appeared in serious productions in the past. But, it re-vitalized the show, grosses went up because they raised the prices, he was only in it for a short time, and grosses dropped drastically when he left.

-- Angela Lansbury in TKAI for three whole weeks, in an attempt to maintain the grosses when Yul Brynner was on vacation. Unfortunately, the show was so associated with Brynner that its grosses fell dramatically, even though the king is a supporting role.

-- Brendan Urie -- never heard of him until the grosses came out, but definitely. Rock star, broadway premiere, brief run, grosses up dramatically.

-- Fran Drescher in Cinderella -- even if it was a small role, they advertised the hell out of it.

-- Jackie Gleason in Sly Fox. Goal was to keep the show running after George C Scott left. Scheduled for a short run. Didn't actually work. Scott was a superstar for a small time period and this as during that time period.

-- The entire cast go the Pearl Bailey 'Hello Dolly'. So much publicity about the basic stunt. I am pretty sure that I read that it was expected to be a limited engagement; but, when the reviews came out, ...

-- Liza Minelli in Chicago. Probably the most successful example that I can think of...turned the show from a likely flop (due to the Chorus Line juggernaut)

-- Sarta Barriles in Waitress

-- Harvey and Rosie in Fiddler?????????? I would argue 'yes'.

-- Darren Criss in How to Succeed...3 weeks only, box office went up dramatically, following Daniel Radcliffe run. There are a lot of tweens with well-off parents.

-- Agree with Sting in The Last Ship, even though it didn't work. The show? the fact that he was not in the lead? Broadway audiences not interested?

-- Emma Stone in Cabaret. Limited engagement from the getgo, grosses went up, show closed shortly after she left, as I recall.

-- Ethel Merman in Hello Dolly???????? Written for her, turned it down, getting close to closing, came in with fanfare for a limited engagement after which the show would close, go out with a bang (after the mega-whimper of Phyllis Diller, I think).

Sure I could think of others if I gave it a little more time.

stunt casting = Wendy Williams as the Matron in CHICAGO. In this case, a person with a somewhat recognizable name who can neither sing, dance or act.

Others:

Sue Ane Langdon - THE APPLE TREE (brief Barbara Harris replacement)

Dorothy Lamour - OH CAPTAIN! (the show closed the week she went in)

Updated On: 11/16/17 at 12:30 PM