Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive- Page 2
Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive
MemorableUserName
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/27/19
#25Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive
Posted: 11/13/24 at 6:02pm
I know not everyone reads posts, but just quoting from quizking101's opening:
"The criteria here, though, is that they must have appeared on Broadway (not off-Broadway or regional) within the last year (so, back to November 2023) and can include replacements."
Some of the previously mentioned don't qualify...
MemorableUserName
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/27/19
#26Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive
Posted: 11/13/24 at 6:08pm
I'll add:
Paulo Szot (& Juliet)
Nicholas Christopher (Sweeney Todd/Hamilton)
#27Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive
Posted: 11/13/24 at 6:41pm
MemorableUserName said: "I know not everyone reads posts, but just quoting from quizking101's opening:
"The criteria here, though, is that they must have appeared on Broadway (not off-Broadway or regional) within the last year (so, back to November 2023) and can include replacements."
Some of the previously mentioned don't qualify..."
THANK YOU! Sweet Jesus…
Check out my eBay page for sales on Playbills!!
www.ebay.com/usr/missvirginiahamm
Matt Rogers
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/4/04
#28Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive
Posted: 11/13/24 at 7:04pm
Nick Adams
Timothy Hughes
Cameron Loyal
All three go to my gym. Grrrrrrr…..
#29Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive
Posted: 11/13/24 at 7:08pm
I'll add one in -- Tally Sessions. I'd have sessions with his tally anytime. 
bwayobsessed
Broadway Star Joined: 5/28/13
#30Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive
Posted: 11/13/24 at 9:52pm
I mean Corey Cott’s arms were the star of Heart of Rock & Roll for a reason
Dolly80
Broadway Star Joined: 5/15/11
#31Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive
Posted: 11/14/24 at 6:35am
Casey Garvin
Cheyenne Jackson
Corey Cott (shame he’s a Trumptard)
#32Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive
Posted: 11/14/24 at 10:05am
Steven9 said: "A common theme I’m noticing in this thread is the lack of body diversity…"
I think what you're noticing is the body type that a very large slice of the population finds attractive. Attraction is attraction, and it can't be reasoned away. The OP asked who the board members find sexy, and they responded accordingly. It is not my intent to be unkind, but were you expecting people to lie about this?
"Michael Riedel...The Perez Hilton of the New York Theatre scene"
- Craig Hepworth, What's On Stage
#33Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive
Posted: 11/14/24 at 10:14am
Steven9 said:
A common theme I’m noticing in this thread is the lack of body diversity…"
You could have helped remedy this by contributing even one name.
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."
Updated On: 11/14/24 at 10:14 AM
Strange Lupone
Stand-by Joined: 5/11/22
#34Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive
Posted: 11/14/24 at 10:18am
Clayton? Sexy AF. Though his self-satisfaction is a massive turn-off. I mean, the video of him wringing out his dance belt at intermission of Crazy For You, while titillating, was such flagrant narcissism that I began to worry for his husband.
All of his curated and posed photos are just too much.
He's absolutely sexy AF. And isn’t at all.
My vote:
Groff. All the way. Groff’s humility, accessibility, talent, heart, and that face? Groff would bring you flowers. Clayton would take pics of himself at the florist telling you he was picking out flowers for his husband. His shirt would be ever so slightly opened and you’d know that the pic you were looking at was the one he chose as the best of the 75 he took (at the flower shop).
Groff. All the way.
“I attended Gypsy last night with several family members that are staying at the same hotel . I walked them to the elevators and as I was leaving, Audra came in fast and this disgusting, huge, ogre of a man came blasting through the revolving door, nearly falling. He got extremely close to her, shoved a playbill in her face and said "I came alllll the way from Houston so you OWE me an autograph sister". Four security guards from the hotel staff immediately swarmed him until the cops arrived. It was horrifying and women have experienced this kind of illegal, terrifying behavior forever.
If you were followed back to where you were staying in the city OP, pretty sure you wouldn't call it "foolery" because it's not. It's felony stalking. Do better.
And I will NEVER be quiet regarding women's safety (especially by loser men in this thread) as this has happened to me and millions of other women as well. Enough..”
—-Sutton Ross, 8/16/25
“Pretty incredible coincidence that the night before this post was made, Sutton was allegedly not only at Gypsy, but ended up at the same hotel, managed to witness an incident that perfectly aligns with the topic at hand, stayed long enough to see how it resolved despite being with family members, and it wasn’t even the first thing she replied to this thread with- she only brought it up after she had been challenged by multiple members. ” — Kad, 8/16/25
mshalo18
Featured Actor Joined: 10/29/22
#35Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive
Posted: 11/14/24 at 12:43pm
Strange Lupone said: "Clayton? Sexy AF. Though his self-satisfaction is a massive turn-off. I mean, the video of him wringing out his dance belt at intermission of Crazy For You, while titillating, was such flagrant narcissism that I began to worry for his husband.
All of his curated and posed photos are just too much.
He's absolutely sexy AF. And isn’t at all.
My vote:
Groff. All the way. Groff’s humility, accessibility, talent, heart, and that face? Groff would bring you flowers. Clayton would take pics of himself at the florist telling you he was picking out flowers for his husband. His shirt would be ever so slightly opened and you’d know that the pic you were looking at was the one he chose as the best of the 75 he took (at the flower shop).
Groff. All the way.
I’m old AF, and I know Groff is gay- but every time he turned around during Merrily, I wanted to pinch his perfect tush.
Strange Lupone
Stand-by Joined: 5/11/22
#36Broadway’s Sexiest Man Alive
Posted: 11/14/24 at 1:19pm
Just pinch? You’re a lot classier than I am!
“I attended Gypsy last night with several family members that are staying at the same hotel . I walked them to the elevators and as I was leaving, Audra came in fast and this disgusting, huge, ogre of a man came blasting through the revolving door, nearly falling. He got extremely close to her, shoved a playbill in her face and said "I came alllll the way from Houston so you OWE me an autograph sister". Four security guards from the hotel staff immediately swarmed him until the cops arrived. It was horrifying and women have experienced this kind of illegal, terrifying behavior forever.
If you were followed back to where you were staying in the city OP, pretty sure you wouldn't call it "foolery" because it's not. It's felony stalking. Do better.
And I will NEVER be quiet regarding women's safety (especially by loser men in this thread) as this has happened to me and millions of other women as well. Enough..”
—-Sutton Ross, 8/16/25
“Pretty incredible coincidence that the night before this post was made, Sutton was allegedly not only at Gypsy, but ended up at the same hotel, managed to witness an incident that perfectly aligns with the topic at hand, stayed long enough to see how it resolved despite being with family members, and it wasn’t even the first thing she replied to this thread with- she only brought it up after she had been challenged by multiple members. ” — Kad, 8/16/25
Videos